Submission Preflight (mind-submission)
The last check before submitting on ScholarOne. Mind is triple-anonymous, so the single most
common avoidable failure is a manuscript that is not properly prepared for anonymous review — such a
paper will not be read. Verify volatile specifics on the official page before relying on them.
When to trigger
- "Submitting tomorrow" — last pass before upload
- Unsure which files / settings ScholarOne expects
- Confirming the word limit, abstract, line numbering, and anonymization are all in order
Process facts (verify volatile items on the official page)
- Owner / publisher: Mind Association / Oxford University Press.
- Portal: ScholarOne (
mc.manuscriptcentral.com/MIND); submit in Word or PDF, with
high-resolution image files sent at the same time.
- Review model: triple-anonymous across all papers — author identity is not revealed to
editors or referees unless and until a paper is accepted; prepare for anonymous refereeing or it
will not be read.
- Scope / what they accept: quality is the sole criterion of publication, with no area, no
style, and no school of philosophy excluded. Content types: articles, discussions (discussion
notes), book reviews, and critical notices.
- Critical notices: longer than book reviews, letting the author develop their own ideas in
response to the book under discussion (distinct from a short book review).
- Volume / competitiveness: the journal receives over 800 submissions each year and draws on a
large pool of expert referees, associate editors, and the Editorial Board. (Acceptance rate and
time-to-first-decision are not published as fixed figures — 需复核.)
- Length: articles no longer than around 8,000 words in total; longer only in exceptional
circumstances (e.g., very extensive quotations from original texts); symbol-heavy papers should
paginate equivalently to an 8,000-word article. (Word limits for discussions / book reviews /
critical notices are not pinned here — 需复核.)
- Abstract: published abstract 50–200 words; a longer submission abstract (up to ~250 words,
待核实) may be included to aid review.
- Submission limit: no more than one article may be submitted by any corresponding author
during any twelve-month period.
- Line numbering: required for the review copy (LaTeX
lineno; Word line-numbering option).
- Style: the MIND Stylesheet / MIND house style applies to the accepted final version;
authors sign the standard OUP copyright licence agreement at acceptance.
- Fee: no submission fee (verified 2026-06-22). An open-access option is available for a
charge, handled by OUP after acceptance; OUP sets the exact APC, eligible licences, and any
read-and-publish / transformative-agreement waivers on its live charges page — confirm there.
Triple-anonymous failure audit
Mind's anonymity rule is not a cosmetic check; an identifying manuscript may not be read. Run a
failure audit with three passes:
- Text pass. Search for first-person self-citations, acknowledgements, grant numbers, conference
versions, appendix URLs, and phrases like "in my earlier paper." Replace with neutral references
where scholarly continuity still matters.
- File pass. Strip document properties, PDF metadata, tracked-change names, embedded comment
authors, and LaTeX build paths that reveal a username or institution.
- Argument pass. Make sure anonymization did not make the paper evasive. Self-citations should
remain intellectually honest, just not identity-revealing.
Record any unavoidable prior-work clue in a private submission note only if the portal requests it.
Preflight checklist
Type & length
Anonymity (triple-anonymous)
Preparation & format
Eligibility & compliance
Anti-patterns
- Uploading a manuscript that reveals the author (triple-anonymous — it will not be read)
- Omitting line numbers from the review copy
- An abstract outside the stated range, or an article well over ~8,000 words with no justification
- Submitting a second article within twelve months as the same corresponding author
- Assuming a default reference export already matches the MIND house style
Output format
【Type】Article / Discussion / Book review / Critical notice (length ok? Y/N)
【Anonymized】text + self-refs + file metadata clean? [Y/N]
【Line numbering】present? [Y/N]
【Abstract】word count (50–200 published)
【12-month rule】clear? [Y/N]
【Format】Word/PDF + images + alt text ready? [Y/N]
【Next】await decision → mind-revision-and-response
Supplementary resources
Source: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills → Mind-Skills/skills/mind-submission/SKILL.md
1---2name: mind-submission3description: "Use when running the final pre-submission preflight for Mind via ScholarOne — preparation for triple-anonymous review, the ~8,000-word limit, the 50–200-word abstract, line numbering, the one-article-per-12-months rule, file format, and the MIND house style. Final checks; it does not draft content."4category: writing-and-content5source_repo: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills6source_path: "Mind-Skills/skills/mind-submission/SKILL.md"7source_url: https://github.com/brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills/blob/HEAD/Mind-Skills/skills/mind-submission/SKILL.md8metadata:9 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/thedixitjain/mind-submission10---111213# Submission Preflight (mind-submission)1415The last check before submitting on **ScholarOne**. Mind is **triple-anonymous**, so the single most16common avoidable failure is a manuscript that is not properly prepared for anonymous review — such a17paper **will not be read**. Verify volatile specifics on the official page before relying on them.1819## When to trigger2021- "Submitting tomorrow" — last pass before upload22- Unsure which files / settings ScholarOne expects23- Confirming the word limit, abstract, line numbering, and anonymization are all in order2425## Process facts (verify volatile items on the official page)2627- **Owner / publisher:** Mind Association / Oxford University Press.28- **Portal:** **ScholarOne** (`mc.manuscriptcentral.com/MIND`); submit in **Word or PDF**, with29 high-resolution image files sent at the same time.30- **Review model:** **triple-anonymous** across all papers — author identity is not revealed to31 editors or referees unless and until a paper is accepted; prepare for anonymous refereeing or it32 will not be read.33- **Scope / what they accept:** **quality is the sole criterion of publication, with no area, no34 style, and no school of philosophy excluded**. Content types: **articles, discussions (discussion35 notes), book reviews, and critical notices**.36- **Critical notices:** **longer than book reviews**, letting the author develop their own ideas in37 response to the book under discussion (distinct from a short book review).38- **Volume / competitiveness:** the journal **receives over 800 submissions each year** and draws on a39 large pool of expert referees, associate editors, and the Editorial Board. (Acceptance rate and40 time-to-first-decision are **not published** as fixed figures — 需复核.)41- **Length:** articles **no longer than around 8,000 words in total**; longer only in **exceptional42 circumstances** (e.g., very extensive quotations from original texts); symbol-heavy papers should43 paginate equivalently to an 8,000-word article. (Word limits for discussions / book reviews /44 critical notices are **not pinned** here — 需复核.)45- **Abstract:** published abstract **50–200 words**; a longer submission abstract (up to ~250 words,46 待核实) may be included to aid review.47- **Submission limit:** **no more than one article may be submitted by any corresponding author48 during any twelve-month period**.49- **Line numbering:** **required** for the review copy (LaTeX `lineno`; Word line-numbering option).50- **Style:** the **MIND Stylesheet / MIND house style** applies to the **accepted** final version;51 authors sign the **standard OUP copyright licence agreement** at acceptance.52- **Fee:** **no submission fee** (verified 2026-06-22). An **open-access option is available for a53 charge**, handled by OUP after acceptance; OUP sets the exact APC, eligible licences, and any54 read-and-publish / transformative-agreement waivers on its live charges page — confirm there.5556## Triple-anonymous failure audit5758Mind's anonymity rule is not a cosmetic check; an identifying manuscript may not be read. Run a59failure audit with three passes:60611. **Text pass.** Search for first-person self-citations, acknowledgements, grant numbers, conference62 versions, appendix URLs, and phrases like "in my earlier paper." Replace with neutral references63 where scholarly continuity still matters.642. **File pass.** Strip document properties, PDF metadata, tracked-change names, embedded comment65 authors, and LaTeX build paths that reveal a username or institution.663. **Argument pass.** Make sure anonymization did not make the paper evasive. Self-citations should67 remain intellectually honest, just not identity-revealing.6869Record any unavoidable prior-work clue in a private submission note only if the portal requests it.7071## Preflight checklist7273### Type & length74- [ ] Content type chosen (article / discussion / book review / critical notice — critical notice is the *longer* book-engagement piece)75- [ ] Article ~8,000 words (or justified exception); symbol-heavy paper paginated equivalently76- [ ] Abstract within the stated length (published 50–200 words)77- [ ] Subject is in scope — quality is the sole criterion; **no area, style, or school of philosophy is excluded**7879### Anonymity (triple-anonymous)80- [ ] No author names, affiliations, or revealing acknowledgements in the manuscript81- [ ] No self-identifying references ("as I argued in…"); self-citations neutralized82- [ ] Identifying **file metadata stripped** (document properties)8384### Preparation & format85- [ ] **Line numbering** on the document (LaTeX `lineno` / Word)86- [ ] Word or PDF; high-resolution image files ready to upload at the same time87- [ ] Consistent citation style (full MIND house-style conversion at acceptance — see `mind-citation-and-style`)88- [ ] Alt text for figures; funding declared where applicable8990### Eligibility & compliance91- [ ] Not in breach of the **one-article-per-12-months** corresponding-author rule92- [ ] Original, unpublished work; aware of the standard OUP copyright licence signed at acceptance93- [ ] No submission fee; if open access is wanted, the OUP charge (APC/Read&Publish 需复核) is settled after acceptance9495## Anti-patterns9697- Uploading a manuscript that reveals the author (triple-anonymous — it will not be read)98- Omitting line numbers from the review copy99- An abstract outside the stated range, or an article well over ~8,000 words with no justification100- Submitting a second article within twelve months as the same corresponding author101- Assuming a default reference export already matches the MIND house style102103## Output format104105```106【Type】Article / Discussion / Book review / Critical notice (length ok? Y/N)107【Anonymized】text + self-refs + file metadata clean? [Y/N]108【Line numbering】present? [Y/N]109【Abstract】word count (50–200 published)110【12-month rule】clear? [Y/N]111【Format】Word/PDF + images + alt text ready? [Y/N]112【Next】await decision → mind-revision-and-response113```114115## Supplementary resources116117- [`../../resources/external_tools.md`](../../resources/external_tools.md) — ScholarOne, LaTeX `lineno`, anonymization, the MIND Stylesheet118- [`../../resources/official-source-map.md`](../../resources/official-source-map.md) — official Mind URLs behind every fact in this pack119120---121122**Source:** [`brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills`](https://github.com/brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills) → `Mind-Skills/skills/mind-submission/SKILL.md`