Emasoft Claude Plugins Validation Skill Validation Skill

Skill Validation Skill

Validates skill directories using 190+ validation rules from:

• AgentSkills OpenSpec — 44 rules
• Nixtla Quality Standards — 52 rules
• Meta-Skill Validation — 47 rules
• Component Validators — 25 rules

Overview

Script-based validation of structure, frontmatter, content, and pillars. For semantic analysis use /cpv-semantic-validation.

Prerequisites

• Python 3.12+ with pyyaml installed
• Skill directory containing a SKILL.md file

Instructions

1. Navigate to the claude-plugins-validation directory
2. Run basic validation:

   uv run python scripts/validate_skill_comprehensive.py path/to/skill/ --report docs_dev/validate_skill_YYYYMMDD.md
   

3. Optionally add mode flags: --strict (Nixtla), --openspec (AgentSkills whitelist), --pillars (8+1 for lang-/convert-)
4. Review the compact summary output (full report saved to file via --report)
5. Fix issues using /cpv-fix-validation <report_path>
6. Re-run validation until exit code 0

Output

• Syntactic Score: 0-100 numeric with tier (PASS / CONDITIONAL_PASS / FAIL)
• Exit Code: 0 (pass), 1 (CRITICAL), 2 (MAJOR), 3 (MINOR), 4 (NIT)
• Report File: Full output saved to docs_dev/validate_skill_YYYYMMDD.md

For Semantic Quality Grading (A-F letter grades), use /cpv-semantic-validation instead.

ALWAYS use --report — never let verbose output consume context.

Error Handling

• "SKILL.md not found": Ensure path points to a skill directory, not a file
• "Malformed YAML": Fix frontmatter syntax (check --- delimiters, quotes, colons)
• "Dir must match skill name": Rename directory or update name field

Examples

Example 1: Basic Validation

uv run python scripts/validate_skill_comprehensive.py ./skills/my-skill/ --report docs_dev/validate_skill_YYYYMMDD.md

Example 2: Full Validation with Pillars

uv run python scripts/validate_skill_comprehensive.py ./skills/lang-rust-dev/ --strict --pillars --verbose --report docs_dev/validate_skill_YYYYMMDD.md

Resources

• Validation Rules

  Structure Validation Rules (8 rules) · Frontmatter Validation Rules (25 rules) · Name Field Validation Rules (12 rules) · Description Quality Rules (15 rules) · Token Budget Rules (8 rules) · Required Sections Rules (9 rules) · Path Format Rules (6 rules) · Resource Reference Rules (8 rules) · Allowed-Tools Rules (10 rules) · 8+1 Pillars Rules (18 rules) · Progressive Disclosure Rules (12 rules) · Content Quality Rules (15 rules) · Agent-Specific Rules (22 rules)

• Frontmatter Schema

  Required Fields · Optional Fields (Claude Code) · Enterprise Fields · Field Validation Details · Field Whitelist Modes · Examples

• Pillars Coverage

  When to Apply Pillars Validation · The 8 Core Pillars · The 9th Pillar (REPL/Workflow) · Scoring System · Coverage Thresholds · Gap Mitigation Strategies · Example Evaluation

• Scoring System

  Multi-Scale Criterion Scoring (0-3) · Tier System (PASS / CONDITIONAL_PASS / FAIL) · Severity Levels · Category Weighting · Overall Score Calculation · Exit Codes · Interpreting Results · Two Scoring Systems

Token Optimization

Always --report <path> — share path, don't read. Prefer LLM Externalizer MCP for report analysis.

Checklist

Copy this checklist and track your progress:

• Run validate_skill_comprehensive.py --report
• Fix issues, re-run until exit 0

Converted and distributed by TomeVault — claim your Tome and manage your conversions.