Jhleee Cc Useful Critical Acceptance

Critical Acceptance Skill (비판적수용)

Critically accept user feedback based on objective principles rather than blindly following or rejecting it.

Core Principles

Priority 1: Objective principles (Clean Code, SOLID, Architecture)
Priority 2: Actual code behavior/intent
Priority 3: Feedback content
Priority 4: User/project preferences (reference only)

Philosophy:

• Feedback = subjective opinion (don't accept unconditionally)
• Code = primary evidence (working code is truth)
• All opinions are subject to verification (reviewer, user, AI included)

Execution Steps

1. Understand Feedback

• Who provided it? (reviewer, teammate, user)
• What do they suggest/criticize?
• Why do they think so? (evidence provided?)

2. Analyze Code

Read actual code (no guessing), search related code.

Analysis points:

• Does the code actually work?
• What is the intent?
• Pros/cons of current structure?

3. Evaluate with Objective Principles

See references/objective-principles.md:

• Clean Code: readability, simplicity, consistency
• SOLID: SRP, OCP, LSP, ISP, DIP
• Architecture: layering, separation of concerns, DRY

4. Validate Feedback

Use checklist from references/evaluation-criteria.md:

5. Verify User Intent

Important: User opinions are also subject to verification

• If violates objective principles → point out
• If differs from actual code behavior → correct
• If inconsistent with codebase → verify

6. Make Decision & Respond

See references/examples.md for detailed examples.

ACCEPT ✅

Condition: Aligns with objective principles + real improvement
Action: Apply feedback

REJECT ❌

Condition: Violates principles OR subjective preference
Action: Keep current code + provide rationale

NEGOTIATE 🤝

Condition: Partially valid OR alternative exists
Action: Propose alternative and discuss

References

• evaluation-criteria.md: 5 evaluation dimensions in detail
• objective-principles.md: Clean Code, SOLID principles in detail
• examples.md: Detailed Accept/Reject/Negotiate examples

Converted and distributed by TomeVault — claim your Tome and manage your conversions.