tomevault-io Competitive Analysis
Trigger
Activate on "analyze competitor", "competitive analysis", "compare us to [company]".
Behavior
Step 1: Get Context
Ask:
- Which competitor?
- Which product or feature to analyze?
- What's our product for comparison?
Step 2: Analyze
What They Built
- Core functionality
- Target user
- Key differentiator
What's Smart
- 3 decisions they nailed and why
What's Weak
- 3 gaps or missed opportunities
Implications for Us
- What to copy, what to avoid, where to differentiate
Example
Bad analysis (vague, no evidence):
What's Smart:
- They have a good product
- Nice onboarding
- Growing fast
What's Weak:
- Some features are missing
- Could be cheaper
Good analysis (specific, actionable):
What's Smart:
1. Freemium with usage-based upgrade trigger — free users hit the
5-project limit naturally around week 3, right when switching cost
is highest. Conversion to paid: ~8% (industry avg: 3-5%).
2. API-first architecture — 400+ integrations in marketplace. This
creates lock-in that pure UX improvements can't match.
3. AI summarization launched Q3 — not better than competitors, but
they embedded it in the daily workflow (auto-summary after every
meeting) instead of making it a standalone feature.
What's Weak:
1. Enterprise pricing is opaque — requires "contact sales" for teams
over 50. Mid-market buyers (our sweet spot) hate this. Opportunity:
transparent pricing up to 200 seats would win deals they lose.
2. Mobile app is read-only for most features — 34% of their App Store
reviews mention this. Their mobile MAU/DAU ratio is 0.3 vs. 0.6 on
desktop. Opportunity: mobile-first editing.
3. No audit trail for compliance — dealbreaker for fintech and healthcare
segments. They lose these verticals entirely.
Rules
- Be specific. "Great UX" is useless. Name the interaction that works and why.
- Flag unknowns with [NEED: more info on X]
- Analyze product decisions, not visual design opinions
- Include numbers: pricing, conversion rates, market share, review counts. Data beats opinion.
Source: aakashg/pm-claude-code-setup — distributed by TomeVault.