Review

Review Command

Behavior Profile

Use the reviewer skill as the behavior profile for this command. Treat its rules as mandatory.

Follow CLAUDE.md, conventions.md, and ARCHITECTURE.md.

Task

Conduct code review and record findings.

Interaction Contract

1. Read issue details and change scope.
2. Perform review and prepare verdict.
3. Show verdict and ask about unrelated issues.
4. Save review comment via beads.

Algorithm

Step 1: Get issue

• If ID missing → ask "Which issue to review?"
• Normalize ID: add DCATgBot- prefix if missing
• Use beads to get issue details
• Determine scope: changed files from branch

Step 2: Review

• Read ARCHITECTURE.md and conventions.md first
• Review checklist: correctness, architecture, security, code quality
• Categorize: related vs unrelated findings
• Produce verdict

Step 3: Confirm

## Review Complete
Status: <verdict>

### Related Findings
<related>

### Unrelated Issues
<unrelated>
---
Create issues for unrelated? (yes/no/select)

Step 4: Record

• Save review as comment via beads
• If approved: create issues for unrelated with discovered-from dependency

Step 5: Report

Needs work:

Review complete. Status: Needs work.
Critical: [C1], [C2]...
Next: /fix <id>

Approved:

Review complete. Status: Approved.
Ready for merge.

Findings Format (for comment)

## Review

**Status:** Needs work | Approved
**Date:** <YYYY-MM-DD>

### Critical
- [C1] Description — `file:line`

### Should Fix
- [S1] Description — `file:line`

### Consider
- [N1] Description — `file:line`

### Verdict
<Summary>

Important

• Never skip verdict confirmation
• Never implement fixes during review
• Use beads for comments and issue creation

Converted and distributed by TomeVault — claim your Tome and manage your conversions.