Roznet Flyfun Apps Iosapp Review

iOS App Architecture Review

Review code changes in app/FlyFunEuroAIP/ for compliance with the architecture defined in designs/IOS_APP_DESIGN.md.

Architecture Rules

1. RZFlight Model Reuse (CRITICAL):

   • Use RZFlight.Airport, RZFlight.Runway, RZFlight.Procedure, RZFlight.AIPEntry directly
   • No duplicate models
   • Query through KnownAirports
   • Extend RZFlight library when functionality is missing

2. Composed AppState:

   • Single source of truth with domain objects
   • Domains: AirportDomain, ChatDomain, NavigationDomain, SystemDomain, SettingsDomain
   • Each domain ~200-400 lines
   • Cross-domain coordination via callbacks
   • Inject via @Environment(\.appState)

3. No ViewModels:

   • Domains replace ViewModels
   • No standalone *ViewModel.swift files
   • ViewCoordinators are structs with computed properties only

4. Repository Pattern:

   • AirportRepositoryProtocol defines unified API
   • LocalAirportDataSource uses KnownAirports
   • Repository returns RZFlight.Airport directly

5. FilterConfig is Pure Data:

   • Simple Codable struct
   • No apply(to:db:) method
   • Filtering logic lives in repository

6. API Adapters:

   • API response models are internal only
   • APIAirportAdapter.toRZFlight() converts immediately
   • Never expose APIAirport outside adapters

7. Region-Based Map Loading:

   • Use airportsInRegion(boundingBox:filters:limit:)
   • Debounce 300ms
   • Limit 500 markers
   • Prefetch with 1.3x padding

8. File-Based Caching:

   • Simple JSON files
   • No SwiftData
   • Cache in Caches/ directory

9. Modern Swift Only (iOS 18.0+/macOS 15.0+):

   • @Observable macro (no ObservableObject)
   • @Environment injection (no @EnvironmentObject)
   • async/await everywhere (no Combine)
   • Modern MapKit with Map { } builder

10. DB is Canonical Source:

    • Local SQLite is truth
    • API is read-only view
    • Full DB replacement for sync

Red Flags

Flag these violations immediately:

• Duplicate models: Creating Airport, Runway in app instead of using RZFlight
• ViewModel files: Any *ViewModel.swift file
• God-class AppState: Single file >500 lines without domain composition
• Direct SQL queries: Using FMDatabase directly instead of KnownAirports
• FilterConfig with DB logic: apply(to:db:) method
• Exposed API models: APIAirport used outside adapter files
• SwiftData usage: Any @Model or SwiftData imports
• ObservableObject: Using instead of @Observable
• Combine imports: Using for state management
• All airports loaded: Loading all 10K+ airports at once for map

Review Process

1. Analyze changed files in app/FlyFunEuroAIP/
2. Check imports - should see import RZFlight, no import Combine
3. Verify model usage - search for RZFlight.Airport vs local Airport
4. Check state management - domains composed in AppState?
5. Verify repository pattern - data access through repository?
6. Check UI patterns - adaptive layouts, environment injection?
7. Identify violations with file paths and line numbers
8. Suggest fixes with code examples

Output Format

APPROVED:

• file:line - Explanation of why it's correct

VIOLATION:

• file:line - Description
• Problem: Why it violates architecture
• Fix: Suggested corrected implementation
• Impact: What breaks (performance, maintainability, etc.)

Key Files

Core Architecture

• App/State/AppState.swift - Composed domains?
• App/State/Domains/*.swift - Each domain ~200-400 lines?
• App/Data/Repositories/AirportRepository.swift - Returns RZFlight types?

Model Usage

• App/Models/*.swift - Should be minimal (app-specific only)
• Any struct Airport - Should NOT exist (use RZFlight.Airport)

UI Layer

• UserInterface/Views/*.swift - Uses @Environment(\.appState)?
• UserInterface/Views/Map/*.swift - Region-based loading?

Approved Patterns

RZFlight Model Usage:

// GOOD
import RZFlight
let airport: Airport  // This is RZFlight.Airport

// BAD
struct AppAirport { let icao: String; let name: String }

Composed AppState:

// GOOD
@Observable @MainActor
final class AppState {
    let airports: AirportDomain
    let chat: ChatDomain
    let navigation: NavigationDomain
}

Environment Injection:

// GOOD
struct AirportMapView: View {
    @Environment(\.appState) private var state
}

// BAD
@StateObject private var viewModel = AirportMapViewModel()

Region-Based Loading:

// GOOD
func onRegionChange(_ region: MKCoordinateRegion) {
    regionUpdateTask?.cancel()
    regionUpdateTask = Task {
        try? await Task.sleep(for: .milliseconds(300))
        airports = try await repository.airportsInRegion(
            boundingBox: region.paddedBy(factor: 1.3).boundingBox,
            filters: filters, limit: 500
        )
    }
}

// BAD
airports = try await repository.allAirports()  // 10K+ airports!

Reference

See designs/IOS_APP_DESIGN.md for full design details.

Converted and distributed by TomeVault — claim your Tome and manage your conversions.