Task Locking

Task Lock Coordination

This skill guides proper use of atomic task locking to prevent race conditions in multi-agent workflows.

Why Atomic Locking Matters

In multi-agent systems, multiple agents can try to work on the same task simultaneously. Without proper locking, you get race conditions:

Agent A reads task (unlocked) ─┐
Agent B reads task (unlocked) ─┤ Race condition!
Agent A acquires lock        ─┤ Both think they got it
Agent B acquires lock        ─┘ Data corruption!

Atomic locking prevents this with a single database operation that's guaranteed to succeed for only ONE agent.

The Atomic Pattern

# GOOD - Atomic single UPDATE (only ONE agent succeeds)
cursor.execute("""
    UPDATE tasks SET lock_holder = ?, lock_expires_at = ?
    WHERE id = ? AND (lock_holder IS NULL OR lock_expires_at < ?)
""", (agent_id, expires_at, task_id, current_time))

success = cursor.rowcount > 0  # Only 1 agent gets rowcount=1

# BAD - Race condition (don't do this!)
if not is_locked(task_id):      # Agent A checks: not locked
    set_lock(task_id, agent_id)  # Agent B can check before A sets!

Tested Under Load

The PM Dashboard locking system has been stress-tested:

• 20+ concurrent agents trying to lock the same task
• Exactly 1 agent succeeds every time
• 19 agents fail gracefully with clear error messages

This is proven to work under extreme concurrency.

Two Locking Approaches

1. Automatic Locking (Preferred)

Use update_task_status() for simple workflows:

# Automatically acquires lock when moving to IN_PROGRESS
update_task_status(
    task_id="42",
    status="IN_PROGRESS",
    agent_id="claude"
)
# Lock acquired automatically!

# Work on task...

# Automatically releases lock when moving to REVIEW or DONE
update_task_status(
    task_id="42",
    status="REVIEW",
    agent_id="claude"
)
# Lock released automatically!

Benefits:

• ✅ Simple - one call does everything
• ✅ No forgotten unlocks
• ✅ Correct workflow enforcement
• ✅ Perfect for single-agent work

When to use: Most of the time!

2. Manual Locking (Multi-Agent Coordination)

Use explicit lock/unlock for complex coordination:

# Agent explicitly acquires lock
success = acquire_task_lock(
    task_id="42",
    agent_id="implementation-agent",
    timeout=300  # 5 minutes
)

if success:
    # Do work...

    # Explicitly release when done
    release_task_lock(
        task_id="42",
        agent_id="implementation-agent"
    )

Benefits:

• ✅ Fine-grained control
• ✅ Custom timeout durations
• ✅ Can hold lock across multiple operations
• ✅ Perfect for multi-agent orchestration

When to use: RA-Full mode, multi-agent workflows, complex coordination.

Lock Lifecycle

1. Task created (unlocked)
         ↓
2. update_task_status(IN_PROGRESS) → Auto-acquires lock
         ↓
3. Agent works on task (lock held)
         ↓
4. update_task_status(REVIEW) → Auto-releases lock
         ↓
5. Reviewer validates (can acquire for review)
         ↓
6. update_task_status(DONE) → Fully unlocked

Lock Timeout & Cleanup

Default timeout: 300 seconds (5 minutes)

Auto-cleanup:

• Expired locks are automatically cleaned up
• System checks for expired locks periodically
• Expired locks are released before new lock attempts

Custom timeout:

acquire_task_lock(
    task_id="42",
    agent_id="long-running-agent",
    timeout=1800  # 30 minutes for complex work
)

Handling Lock Failures

Scenario 1: Task Already Locked

success = acquire_task_lock(task_id="42", agent_id="agent-A")

if not success:
    # Check who has the lock
    lock_status = get_task_lock_status(task_id="42")

    if lock_status["is_locked"]:
        print(f"Task locked by: {lock_status['lock_holder']}")
        print(f"Expires at: {lock_status['lock_expires_at']}")

        # Options:
        # 1. Wait for lock to expire
        # 2. Work on different task
        # 3. Coordinate with lock holder

Scenario 2: Lock Expired While Working

# Lock acquired with 5-minute timeout
acquire_task_lock(task_id="42", agent_id="slow-agent", timeout=300)

# ... work takes 10 minutes (timeout exceeded!) ...

# Try to update status
update_task_status(task_id="42", status="DONE", agent_id="slow-agent")
# ❌ Fails: "Task must be locked by agent to update status"

# Solution: Re-acquire lock before finishing
success = acquire_task_lock(task_id="42", agent_id="slow-agent")
if success:
    update_task_status(task_id="42", status="DONE", agent_id="slow-agent")

Multi-Agent Orchestration Example

RA-Full mode with multiple agents:

# Main orchestrator creates task
create_task(name="Complex feature", ra_mode="ra-full", ra_score="9")

# Deploy survey agent
acquire_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="survey-agent", timeout=600)
# Survey agent gathers context...
release_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="survey-agent")

# Deploy planning agent
acquire_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="planning-agent", timeout=600)
# Planning agent creates plan...
release_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="planning-agent")

# Deploy implementation agent
acquire_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="impl-agent", timeout=1800)
# Implementation agent codes...
release_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="impl-agent")

# Deploy verification agent
acquire_task_lock(task_id="99", agent_id="verify-agent", timeout=600)
# Verification agent reviews...
update_task_status(task_id="99", status="DONE", agent_id="verify-agent")
# Auto-releases on DONE

Lock Ownership Validation

Only the lock holder can:

• Update task status
• Release the lock
• Modify task data

# Agent A has the lock
acquire_task_lock(task_id="42", agent_id="agent-A")

# Agent B tries to update
update_task_status(task_id="42", status="DONE", agent_id="agent-B")
# ❌ Fails: "Task is locked by agent-A"

# Only Agent A can update
update_task_status(task_id="42", status="DONE", agent_id="agent-A")
# ✅ Success

Best Practices

✅ DO

• Use auto-locking (update_task_status) for simple workflows
• Set appropriate timeouts based on work complexity
• Release locks explicitly if using manual locking
• Check lock status before attempting operations
• Log lock failures for debugging

❌ DON'T

• Don't forget to release manual locks
• Don't use SELECT then UPDATE (race condition risk)
• Don't hold locks longer than necessary
• Don't assume lock still held after long work
• Don't try to steal locks from other agents

Common Patterns

Pattern 1: Quick Update

# Auto-lock pattern (preferred)
update_task_status(task_id, "IN_PROGRESS", agent_id)
# ... quick work ...
update_task_status(task_id, "DONE", agent_id)

Pattern 2: Long Work Session

# Manual lock with custom timeout
acquire_task_lock(task_id, agent_id, timeout=1800)  # 30 min
try:
    # ... long complex work ...
finally:
    release_task_lock(task_id, agent_id)  # Always release!

Pattern 3: Check Before Acquire

# Check if available first
lock_status = get_task_lock_status(task_id)
if not lock_status["is_locked"]:
    success = acquire_task_lock(task_id, agent_id)
    if success:
        # Do work
        pass

Debugging Lock Issues

Problem: "Task must be locked"

Cause: Lock expired or never acquired Solution: Check timeout, re-acquire if needed

Problem: "Task is locked by another agent"

Cause: Another agent has the lock Solution: Wait for expiration or coordinate

Problem: Lock never released

Cause: Agent crashed or forgot to release Solution: Wait for auto-cleanup (timeout expiration)

Database Implementation

The atomic locking is implemented with a single UPDATE:

UPDATE tasks
SET lock_holder = ?, lock_expires_at = ?, updated_at = ?
WHERE id = ?
  AND (lock_holder IS NULL OR lock_expires_at < ?)

Why this works:

• WHERE clause filters to unlocked or expired locks
• Only ONE concurrent UPDATE can satisfy the WHERE clause
• rowcount > 0 tells you if YOU got the lock
• Atomic at database level (tested under 20-agent load)

Summary

Simple workflows: Use update_task_status() auto-locking

Complex workflows: Use acquire_task_lock() + release_task_lock() manually

Always:

• Set appropriate timeouts
• Release locks when done
• Check lock status before operations
• Trust the atomic pattern (it's tested!)

The PM Dashboard locking system is production-ready and proven under concurrent load.

Converted and distributed by TomeVault — claim your Tome and manage your conversions.