Triage Pr

PR Review Comment Triage

Triage all review comments on PR #$ARGUMENTS in the current repository.

CRITICAL: Do NOT reply to any comments, modify any code, or take any action until the user explicitly approves. This workflow is report-first, act-later.

Step 1: Fetch comments

Use gh api to fetch:

• Pull request review comments: gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pr}/comments
• General issue comments: gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{pr}/comments
• Reviews summary: gh pr view {pr} --json reviews

Extract the owner/repo from the current git remote.

Step 2: Analyze each comment

For every review comment, read the actual source code referenced by the comment before judging. Do not rely solely on the diff hunk. Classify each comment as:

• Valid — Should Fix: A genuine bug, correctness issue, missing state update, or meaningful improvement.
• Valid — Style/Nice-to-have: Correct observation but low priority (naming, minor refactors).
• False Positive: The reviewer misunderstood the code, the concern doesn't apply in context, or the suggestion is strictly worse. Common false positives include:
  • Coordinate system swaps that are intentional
  • "Implicit filtering" style nits when if/continue is idiomatic
  • Integer overflow warnings on small UI values
  • Suggestions that introduce double work (e.g., calling TryParse twice)
  • Unreachable edge cases due to known data constraints

Step 3: Present the report

Present a full report to the user with these sections. Skip bot comments (Cloudflare deploy notifications, CI status, etc.).

Valid Issues — Should Fix

Valid Issues — Style/Nice-to-have

False Positives

Step 4: Wait for user approval

After presenting the report, ask the user what they want to do. Offer these options:

1. Fix valid issues + reply to false positives — apply code fixes, reply to false positives on GitHub, commit and push
2. Fix valid issues only — apply code fixes, commit and push, don't reply on GitHub
3. Reply to false positives only — post replies on GitHub, don't change code
4. Do nothing — the report was informational only

For replying to false positives, use:

gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pr}/comments/{comment_id}/replies -X POST -f body="..."

Group similar false positives — reply to the first in a cluster and note it covers the others.

For code fixes:

1. Apply the fixes
2. Run dotnet build to verify
3. Commit with a message referencing the PR review
4. Push to the branch

Do NOT merge or close the PR.

Source: mizrael/OpenSleigh — distributed by TomeVault.