tools-only /board-review — Quick Expert Assessment
Run a quick assessment from the 5-member Board of Directors. Each director provides their expert opinion in parallel, without the discussion phase.
Usage
/board-review [proposal or leave blank to review current track]
Workflow
- Load Proposal — From argument or current track's plan.md
- Parallel Assessment — All 5 directors evaluate simultaneously
- Aggregate Results — Combine verdicts into summary
Directors
| Director | Domain |
|---|---|
| CA - Chief Architect | Technical design, scalability, patterns |
| CPO - Chief Product Officer | User value, market fit, scope |
| CSO - Chief Security Officer | Security, compliance, risk |
| COO - Chief Operations Officer | Feasibility, timeline, resources |
| CXO - Chief Experience Officer | UX/UI, accessibility, design |
Execution
// Dispatch all 5 directors in parallel
const assessments = await Promise.all([
Task({
subagent_type: "general-purpose",
description: "CA board assessment",
prompt: `You are the Chief Architect.
Proposal: ${proposal}
Follow .claude/skills/board-of-directors/directors/chief-architect.md
Output JSON assessment.`
}),
// ... CPO, CSO, COO, CXO
]);
Output Format
## Quick Board Review
**Proposal**: [summary]
| Director | Verdict | Score | Top Concern |
|----------|---------|-------|-------------|
| CA | APPROVE | 8/10 | Query performance |
| CPO | APPROVE | 9/10 | None |
| CSO | CONCERNS | 6/10 | Rate limiting missing |
| COO | APPROVE | 7/10 | Timeline tight |
| CXO | APPROVE | 8/10 | Minor a11y issues |
**Quick Verdict**: 4-1 APPROVE with conditions
**Key Conditions**:
1. Add rate limiting (CSO)
2. Add query caching (CA)