tools-only Comparative Analysis
Opus: Naturally structures comparisons. Weighs trade-offs. Arrives at nuanced conclusions that acknowledge context-dependency.
Haiku: Comparisons tend toward surface-level listing of differences. May not weigh factors or synthesize into a recommendation. Can produce unbalanced comparisons (more detail on first item than last).
Mitigation: Provide the comparison framework explicitly.
Compare using EXACTLY these dimensions:
1. Cost (provide specific numbers if available)
2. Performance (cite metrics from the data)
3. Ease of use (based on stated requirements)
For each dimension:
- State Option A's position in one sentence
- State Option B's position in one sentence
- Declare a winner for that dimension: A, B, or TIE
After all dimensions, provide:
Overall recommendation: A or B
Reasoning: one sentence citing the decisive factor.
For balanced treatment:
- Use a table format (enforces equal space per option)
- Specify equal word counts per option
- Process options in consistent order across dimensions