Phase Review

/phase-review

Run the Evaluate Execution step of the Evaluate-Loop workflow. This is the mandatory quality gate before marking any track or phase complete.

When to Use

Run this command:

• After finishing all tasks in a track/phase (Step 4 of the Evaluate-Loop)
• Before marking anything as complete in tracks.md
• When you want to verify alignment between plan and execution

What It Does

1. Reads the current track's spec.md and plan.md
2. Runs the full post-execution evaluation checklist
3. Identifies misalignment between plan and execution
4. Checks all deliverables are present and functional
5. Runs usability check on user-facing changes
6. Checks build passes with no console errors
7. Generates a Phase Completion Report with PASS/FAIL verdict

Usage

/phase-review

Or with a specific track:

/phase-review TRACK-001-feature-implementation

Evaluation Checklist

The command verifies all checks from the Evaluate-Loop:

1. Deliverables Check

• All deliverables from spec.md are present
• Each deliverable matches acceptance criteria
• No placeholder or incomplete content

2. Alignment Check (Prevents Scope Drift)

• Implementation matches what plan.md described
• No unplanned work was added without documentation
• No planned work was skipped
• plan.md is fully updated with [x] markers and summaries

3. Quality Gates

• Usability check applied to user-facing changes
• No console errors or warnings
• Build completes successfully

4. Regression Check

• Existing features still work
• No broken imports or dead references
• Pages render without errors

5. Testing (when applicable)

• Unit tests pass
• Coverage meets thresholds:
  • Overall: 70%
  • Business logic: 90%
  • API routes: 80%
• Manual testing completed per workflow.md checklist

6. Documentation

• Code documented where non-obvious
• plan.md fully updated with task completion summaries
• Track ready for next session to pick up without confusion

Output Format

The command generates a completion report:

## Phase Completion Report

**Track**: [Track Name]
**Date**: [YYYY-MM-DD]
**Evaluation**: PASS | FAIL

### Deliverables
- [x] Deliverable 1 - src/components/auth/signup-form.tsx
- [x] Deliverable 2 - src/lib/api-client.ts
- [ ] Deliverable 3 - MISSING: src/hooks/useFeature.ts

### Alignment
- [x] All planned tasks executed
- [ ] DRIFT: Design system was rebuilt (not in plan)

### Quality Gates
- [x] Usability check (3 UI changes reviewed)
- [x] No console errors
- [x] Build successful

### Issues Found
1. [Issue description and severity]

### Verdict
PASS — Ready to mark complete
  OR
FAIL — Fix required before completion
  - Fix 1: [description]
  - Fix 2: [description]

What Happens After

If PASS

1. Mark track complete in tracks.md
2. Update conductor/index.md current status
3. Commit: docs: complete [TRACK-NAME] - evaluation passed

If FAIL

1. Create fix tasks in plan.md
2. Execute the fixes (Step 3 of the Evaluate-Loop)
3. Re-run /phase-review (loop back to Step 4)
4. Repeat until PASS

Related

• conductor/workflow.md — Evaluate-Loop Process (primary reference)
• CLAUDE.md — Mandatory Agent Rules
• /conductor status — See current track status
• /conductor implement — Execute track tasks