Output Reviewer Skill
When to activate
Before sending any newsletter, or when user runs /review-draft to audit a complete newsletter for quality, brand fit, and engagement potential.
When NOT to use
Do not use this skill to evaluate drafts that are still in early ideation—wait until a complete draft exists.
Instructions
Check engagement hooks
- Does the opening sentence intrigue or provoke?
- Is it specific (not generic)?
- Would a subscriber want to keep reading?
- Flag if hook is weak or unclear
Verify clarity and readability
- Each section has one clear idea
- Sentences are short and active voice
- No unexplained jargon or acronyms
- Technical terms are defined
- Flag any sections that feel unclear or redundant
Scan for banned words and tone slips
- Search for: synergy, revolutionary, game-changer, delve, robust, leverage, holistic, ecosystem, disruptive, innovative, paradigm, seamlessly, unlock value, reach out, per my last email
- Check tone is conversational, not corporate
- Verify voice is knowledgeable, not patronizing
- Flag tone issues with examples and fixes
Validate structure and length
- Body is 300–800 words? Optimal is 500–600
- Subject line is <50 characters?
- Preview text is 40–80 characters?
- CTA is single and clear?
- No link sprawl?
- Flag length or structure issues with specific counts
Check brand consistency
- Does this align with the newsletter's voice and values?
- Does it match prior newsletters in style and depth?
- Appropriate for the audience?
- Flag any misalignment with brand guidelines
Verify all sources and claims
- Are data points attributed to a source?
- Are expert quotes accurate and sourced?
- Are any claims too broad or unsupported?
- Flag unverified claims or missing attribution
Validate links and CTAs
- Are all URLs properly formatted (http/https)?
- Do they exist and are they relevant?
- Is the CTA clear and actionable?
- Flag broken, missing, or vague CTAs
Generate audit report
- Pass/Fail decision (Ready to Send / Needs Edits)
- Issues found (if any) with examples and fixes
- Suggestions for improvement
- Estimated impact on open rate and engagement
Format
## REVIEW REPORT: [Newsletter Title]
**Status:** [PASS / NEEDS EDITS]
**Summary:** [1–2 sentences on overall quality and readiness]
### Engagement & Hook
[Analysis of opening, interest factor, specificity]
- [ ] Strong opening hook
- [x] Clear audience value
- [ ] Specific and data-backed
### Clarity & Readability
[Analysis of structure, jargon, flow]
- [x] Clear sections with single ideas
- [x] No unexplained jargon
- [x] Active voice throughout
### Tone & Brand Fit
[Analysis of voice, authority, brand alignment]
- [x] Conversational and expert
- [x] Consistent with prior newsletters
- [ ] Issue: Uses "ecosystem" once — suggest "context" instead
### Length & Structure
- Body: 487 words [✓ within 300–800 range]
- Subject line: "5 AI Trends..." [✓ 19 chars]
- Preview text: "Here's what actually..." [✓ 45 chars]
- CTA: Single, clear [✓]
### Sources & Accuracy
- [x] 2 data points with sources
- [x] 2 expert quotes with attribution
- [x] No unsupported claims
### Links & CTAs
- [x] 2 links tested and working
- [x] CTA is specific ("reply with your biggest blocker")
### Brand Alignment
[Analysis vs. audience and prior newsletters]
- [x] Appropriate depth for audience
- [x] Matches tone of prior editions
- [x] Clear value for subscriber
---
## ISSUES FOUND
**Minor (1):**
1. Line 3, "Enterprises stopped chasing every AI announcement" — add specific reason why (e.g., "after $X billion in failed pilots")
**None**
---
## RECOMMENDATION
**Status:** PASS — Ready to send with optional minor edit above.
**Estimated Open Rate:** 28–32% (strong hook, specific data, expert voices)
**Estimated CTR:** 5–7% (clear CTA, relevant resource)
**Next Steps:** Optional edit on Minor issue above. Subject line test: Use Option A ("5 AI Trends...") for highest predicted open rate vs. Options B and C.
Tags: #quality-assurance #content-review #editorial-checklist
1---2name: output-reviewer-23description: Output Reviewer Skill4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/uitbreidenos/output-reviewer-26---7# Output Reviewer Skill89## When to activate10Before sending any newsletter, or when user runs `/review-draft` to audit a complete newsletter for quality, brand fit, and engagement potential.1112## When NOT to use13Do not use this skill to evaluate drafts that are still in early ideation—wait until a complete draft exists.1415## Instructions16171. **Check engagement hooks**18 - Does the opening sentence intrigue or provoke?19 - Is it specific (not generic)?20 - Would a subscriber want to keep reading?21 - Flag if hook is weak or unclear22232. **Verify clarity and readability**24 - Each section has one clear idea25 - Sentences are short and active voice26 - No unexplained jargon or acronyms27 - Technical terms are defined28 - Flag any sections that feel unclear or redundant29303. **Scan for banned words and tone slips**31 - Search for: synergy, revolutionary, game-changer, delve, robust, leverage, holistic, ecosystem, disruptive, innovative, paradigm, seamlessly, unlock value, reach out, per my last email32 - Check tone is conversational, not corporate33 - Verify voice is knowledgeable, not patronizing34 - Flag tone issues with examples and fixes35364. **Validate structure and length**37 - Body is 300–800 words? Optimal is 500–60038 - Subject line is <50 characters?39 - Preview text is 40–80 characters?40 - CTA is single and clear?41 - No link sprawl?42 - Flag length or structure issues with specific counts43445. **Check brand consistency**45 - Does this align with the newsletter's voice and values?46 - Does it match prior newsletters in style and depth?47 - Appropriate for the audience?48 - Flag any misalignment with brand guidelines49506. **Verify all sources and claims**51 - Are data points attributed to a source?52 - Are expert quotes accurate and sourced?53 - Are any claims too broad or unsupported?54 - Flag unverified claims or missing attribution55567. **Validate links and CTAs**57 - Are all URLs properly formatted (http/https)?58 - Do they exist and are they relevant?59 - Is the CTA clear and actionable?60 - Flag broken, missing, or vague CTAs61628. **Generate audit report**63 - Pass/Fail decision (Ready to Send / Needs Edits)64 - Issues found (if any) with examples and fixes65 - Suggestions for improvement66 - Estimated impact on open rate and engagement6768## Format6970```71## REVIEW REPORT: [Newsletter Title]7273**Status:** [PASS / NEEDS EDITS]7475**Summary:** [1–2 sentences on overall quality and readiness]7677### Engagement & Hook78[Analysis of opening, interest factor, specificity]79- [ ] Strong opening hook80- [x] Clear audience value81- [ ] Specific and data-backed8283### Clarity & Readability84[Analysis of structure, jargon, flow]85- [x] Clear sections with single ideas86- [x] No unexplained jargon87- [x] Active voice throughout8889### Tone & Brand Fit90[Analysis of voice, authority, brand alignment]91- [x] Conversational and expert92- [x] Consistent with prior newsletters93- [ ] Issue: Uses "ecosystem" once — suggest "context" instead9495### Length & Structure96- Body: 487 words [✓ within 300–800 range]97- Subject line: "5 AI Trends..." [✓ 19 chars]98- Preview text: "Here's what actually..." [✓ 45 chars]99- CTA: Single, clear [✓]100101### Sources & Accuracy102- [x] 2 data points with sources103- [x] 2 expert quotes with attribution104- [x] No unsupported claims105106### Links & CTAs107- [x] 2 links tested and working108- [x] CTA is specific ("reply with your biggest blocker")109110### Brand Alignment111[Analysis vs. audience and prior newsletters]112- [x] Appropriate depth for audience113- [x] Matches tone of prior editions114- [x] Clear value for subscriber115116---117118## ISSUES FOUND119120**Minor (1):**1211. Line 3, "Enterprises stopped chasing every AI announcement" — add specific reason why (e.g., "after $X billion in failed pilots")122123**None**124125---126127## RECOMMENDATION128129**Status:** PASS — Ready to send with optional minor edit above.130131**Estimated Open Rate:** 28–32% (strong hook, specific data, expert voices)132**Estimated CTR:** 5–7% (clear CTA, relevant resource)133134**Next Steps:** Optional edit on Minor issue above. Subject line test: Use Option A ("5 AI Trends...") for highest predicted open rate vs. Options B and C.135```136137---138139**Tags:** #quality-assurance #content-review #editorial-checklist