Plan Reviewer
Critically analyze implementation plans for quality, completeness, and feasibility.
When to Activate
- User has a plan file to review
- Validation needed before execution
- Feedback requested on implementation strategy
- User asks "does this plan look good?"
- Before executing a planned implementation
Workflow Integration
This is Step 3 of the implementation workflow:
- Explore → 2. Plan → 3. Review (this) → 4. Execute
Quick Process
- Load Plan: Read the plan file
- Analyze: Check completeness and conciseness
- Validate Scope: Ensure no extras beyond requirements
- Identify Risks: Report the implementation risks you find, each with a severity
- Check Alignment: Verify against codebase patterns
- Provide Feedback: Actionable improvement suggestions
Output Format
Returns structured review:
- Summary: Plan quality and main assessment
- Strengths: What the plan does well
- Concerns: Issues with severity and suggestions
- Gaps: Missing critical elements
- Improvements: Enhancement recommendations
- Feasibility: Complexity and risks with severity
- Alignment: Pattern compliance check
- Scope Validation: Requirements adherence
Review Focus Areas
security: Security considerations and vulnerabilitiesperformance: Performance implications and optimizationsdefault: All aspects
Context Integration
Automatically uses context from a prior explore-codebase run when available:
- Key components and responsibilities
- Existing patterns and conventions
- Dependencies and integration points
- Known gotchas and edge cases
Delegation
Invokes plan-reviewer-agent with plan file and context.