Utoo Upstream Sync

Utoo Upstream Sync

This skill helps sync upstream vercel/next.js changes into this repository's next.js submodule. Keep the skill in this repository, not inside the next.js submodule, because submodule changes are committed to the utooland/next.js fork and should stay as close to upstream as possible.

In this workflow, next.js is the submodule directory and may also be used locally as a remote name; turbopack/ is a subtree inside upstream vercel/next.js, not a separate upstream repository.

Repository Model

• Current repository: the working tree where this skill is installed
• Submodule directory: next.js
• Submodule repository: utooland/next.js
• Submodule integration branch: utoo
• Upstream repository: vercel/next.js
• Upstream branch: canary
• Sync operation: rebase utooland/next.js branch utoo onto upstream vercel/next.js branch canary
• Submodule commits must be made inside next.js.
• Keep submodule changes minimal and directly related to syncing or adapting upstream vercel/next.js.
• Current repository commits should record the submodule pointer separately from local adapter fixes when practical.
• Do not commit local generated files unless explicitly requested, especially:
  • packages/utoo-web/src/utoo/index.d.ts
  • report/

Default Workflow

1. Inspect both worktrees before changing anything:

   git status --short --branch
   git -C next.js status --short --branch
   

2. In the next.js submodule, identify the merge base between the utoo branch and upstream vercel/next.js canary.

   The exact remote names can differ by maintainer. Determine them from git remote -v instead of assuming origin or upstream.

   git -C next.js remote -v
   git -C next.js merge-base <utooland-next-remote>/utoo <vercel-next-remote>/canary
   

3. List upstream commits after the merge base and filter for Turbopack/TurboTasks related changes.

   Start with keywords such as turbo, turbopack, and task, but do not rely on keywords alone. Read commit titles and, for suspicious commits, inspect the diff or commit message to decide whether it affects turbopack/, turbo-tasks, shared Rust APIs, runtime output, wasm, or local utoo patches.

   git -C next.js log --oneline <merge-base>..<vercel-next-remote>/canary
   git -C next.js log --oneline <merge-base>..<vercel-next-remote>/canary | rg -i "(turbo|task)"
   

4. Mark risky upstream commits before rebasing. The goal is to choose rebase breakpoints where each stop is likely caused by one upstream commit or one coherent module/API change.

   Risk signals:

   • touches high-risk areas listed below
   • changes public Rust APIs used by local crates/pack-*
   • changes generated runtime output or snapshot-sensitive behavior
   • changes Cargo dependencies, toolchains, wasm, or CI assumptions
   • overlaps known utoo patches in next.js
   • appears to implement behavior that an existing utoo patch already carries

5. Before rebasing, print the Turbopack-related upstream history and mark the selected breakpoints.

   The user does not need to approve every breakpoint, but they should be able to see the plan. Include enough context to show why each breakpoint was selected.

   Example format:

   Turbopack-related upstream commits after <merge-base>:
   [breakpoint] 0070514701 Turbopack: make available_modules an OperationVc ...
                1b77dba691 Turbopack: Fix unsound IntoIterator for ReadRef<T>
   [breakpoint] 5ee7005200 Turbopack: use module graph for NFT
                ...
   

6. Rebase in stages using the selected breakpoints, not as one large jump.

   At each breakpoint:

   • resolve conflicts caused by that upstream commit/module change
   • run the smallest verification that covers the touched area
   • for conflicts, build failures, or snapshot failures, identify the causing upstream update, explain why it broke, propose a fix, and wait for user confirmation before editing
   • if an existing utoo patch is now implemented upstream, drop that patch commit only after explaining which patch is covered, which upstream commit covers it, and why the local patch is no longer needed
   • prefer fixes that are easy for a human to review as one feature/module adaptation

7. Keep utoo-specific behavior when it is intentional:

   • wasm guards
   • lightningcss fork usage
   • pack-core / pack-api public API behavior
   • utoo-web wasm build requirements

8. Prefer upstream semantics for shared Turbopack/TurboTasks APIs.

9. Make the smallest compatible local adapter change.

10. Verify the exact path that failed.

11. Commit only related files.

User Confirmation Gate

Do not silently fix these cases:

• rebase conflicts
• compile failures after a rebase breakpoint
• snapshot test failures
• CI failures that imply code or snapshot changes
• dependency or lockfile conflicts

For these, first report:

• which upstream commit or upstream change likely caused it
• what changed upstream
• why local utoo code, patches, snapshots, or CI assumptions broke
• the proposed fix and why it is the right direction
• any alternatives or risk if the fix is not obvious

Only edit files after the user confirms the proposed direction.

High-Risk Upstream Areas

Set rebase breakpoints or inspect carefully around commits touching:

• turbo_tasks::Vc, ResolvedVc, ReadRef, OperationVc
• resolve APIs: ResolveResult, ModuleResolveResult, first_module, first_source, primary_modules
• chunking APIs: make_chunk_group, evaluated_chunk_group, ChunkGroupResult, availability info
• EcmascriptChunkItem, ChunkItem, resolve plugins, BeforeResolvePlugin, AfterResolvePlugin
• turbo-rcstr, rcstr!, static atoms, inline atom size
• turbo-tasks strongly consistent reads and #[turbo_tasks::function(root)]
• file tracing / NFT
• runtime output snapshots
• wasm, worker threads, wasm-bindgen, -Z build-std
• new std::* calls incompatible with wasm32-unknown-unknown (see adaptation patterns below)
• newly introduced third-party crates that may not compile or run on wasm32-unknown-unknown

Common Adaptation Patterns

Vc methods moved to inner values

If an API now exists on T instead of Vc<T>, await first:

result.await?.first_module().await?
result.await?.primary_modules().await?

Do not keep old direct calls like:

result.first_module().await?

first_module() now returns Option<ResolvedVc<_>>

Do not dereference the Option.

Use:

let Some(module) = result.await?.first_module().await? else {
    return Ok(None);
};

Avoid:

let Some(module) = &*result.await?.first_module().await? else { ... };

ReadRef iteration

After upstream fixes to ReadRef<T> iteration, avoid direct owned iteration unless the type supports it.

Prefer:

for item in &read_ref {
    // ...
}

or explicitly access/copy owned data if needed.

ResolvedVc vs Vc

Check function signatures before converting.

• Expected Vc<T>, found ResolvedVc<T>: often use *resolved.
• Expected ResolvedVc<T>, found Vc<T>: often use .to_resolved().await?.
• Do not mechanically add *; compare with upstream call sites first.

Resolve API

Typical new patterns:

origin
    .resolve_asset(request, origin.resolve_options(), ty)
    .await?
    .await?
    .primary_modules()
    .await?

For one module:

let Some(module) = resolved.await?.first_module().await? else {
    bail!("unable to resolve ...");
};

Chunking API

When evaluated_chunk_group / evaluated_chunk_group_assets gains extra chunks:

• Update trait impl and all callers together.
• For no extra assets, pass OutputAssets::empty() or the current upstream equivalent.
• If make_chunk_group now takes entries rather than ChunkGroup, pass chunk_group.entries().
• Match Vc<ModuleGraph> vs ResolvedVc<ModuleGraph> exactly.

Diagnostics removal

If turbopack_core::diagnostics is gone:

• Do not add compatibility APIs unless the JS package consumes them.
• Prefer upstream issue/collectibles flow.
• If package consumers do not read diagnostics, remove diagnostics fields from API/test structs.

RcStr and wasm

Upstream rcstr! static atom optimizations can break wasm or const eval.

Rules:

• wasm long strings must not materialize pointer-backed static atoms in const eval.

• native long-string expansion should keep static prehashed storage, but return RcStr by runtime wrapping:

  static RCSTR_STORAGE: StaticPrehashedString = make_const_prehashed_string("...");
  from_static(&RCSTR_STORAGE)
  

• Avoid:

  const RCSTR: RcStr = from_static(&RCSTR_STORAGE);
  

• utoo-wasm needs:

  turbo-rcstr = { workspace = true, features = ["atom_size_128"], optional = true }
  

• threaded wasm-bindgen builds need:

  "-Clink-arg=--export=__heap_base",
  

wasm32-unknown-unknown std API compatibility

Upstream turbopack code targets native platforms. New std calls that work on native may panic or fail to compile on wasm32-unknown-unknown. During sync, grep newly added or modified files for the APIs below and gate or replace them.

Incompatible std APIs — comprehensive list:

Detection during sync:

# After rebasing, scan newly changed turbopack files for risky std calls
git -C next.js diff <merge-base>..HEAD --name-only -- '*.rs' | \
  xargs rg -n '(std::time::Instant|std::time::SystemTime|std::thread::(spawn|sleep|park|Builder|JoinHandle|available_parallelism)|std::sync::(Condvar|Barrier|mpsc)|std::fs::|std::net::|std::process::|std::env::(var|current_dir|current_exe|args))'

If any match is found in code reachable from the utoo-wasm build:

1. Report the call site, the upstream commit that introduced it, and why it breaks wasm.
2. Propose one of:
   • #[cfg(not(all(target_family = "wasm", target_os = "unknown")))] gate with a wasm-compatible alternative
   • Replacement with a forked-tokio or wasm-compatible equivalent
   • Upstream conditional compilation if the code already has platform gates
3. Wait for user confirmation before editing.

Third-party crate wasm compatibility

Upstream turbopack may introduce new third-party crate dependencies. Not all crates compile or run correctly on wasm32-unknown-unknown.

Detection during sync:

# After rebasing, diff Cargo.toml files for new dependencies
git -C next.js diff <merge-base>..HEAD -- '**/Cargo.toml' | rg '^\+.*=.*\{' | rg -v '\[dev-dependencies\]'

Evaluation checklist for each newly introduced crate:

1. Check crate metadata: Does the crate list wasm32-unknown-unknown as a supported target? Check Cargo.toml for [target.'cfg(...)'.dependencies] gates.

2. Check transitive deps: Does the crate pull in known wasm-incompatible crates (ring, native-tls, openssl-sys, mio with epoll/kqueue, tokio with rt-multi-thread, rayon, etc.)?

3. Check for C/system deps: Does the crate use cc, cmake, pkg-config, or links = "..." in its build script? These typically fail on wasm.

4. Check for std::thread / std::net / std::fs: Does the crate internally use APIs from the incompatible list above?

5. Quick smoke test:

   # Try compiling the crate alone for wasm
   cargo check --target wasm32-unknown-unknown -p <crate-name>
   

If a new crate is wasm-incompatible:

1. Report the crate name, which upstream commit introduced it, and what makes it incompatible.
2. Propose one of:
   • Feature-gate the dependency: [target.'cfg(not(all(target_family = "wasm", target_os = "unknown")))'.dependencies]
   • Find a wasm-compatible alternative crate
   • Fork or patch the crate if a small fix is sufficient
   • Gate the consuming code path with #[cfg(not(all(target_family = "wasm", target_os = "unknown")))]
3. Flag for user review — do not silently add wasm-incompatible dependencies.

Known wasm-incompatible crate patterns:

Rust toolchain sync

Keep these aligned:

• current repository rust-toolchain.toml
• submodule next.js/rust-toolchain.toml
• workflow Rust toolchain: values
• explicit rustup install/default nightly-... commands

If CI installs one nightly but rust-toolchain.toml selects another, -Z build-std may fail because rust-src was installed for the wrong toolchain.

Verification Matrix

Run the smallest command that covers the failure.

General Rust

cargo check
cargo clippy -p pack-api -- -D warnings
cargo nextest r -p pack-tests

Pack plugin feature

Required when packages/pack, pack-napi, SWC plugins, or plugin feature paths are touched:

cargo build --features plugin -p pack-napi --profile release-local

utoo-web wasm

From packages/utoo-web:

ut build:local

This validates:

• wasm target
• -Z build-std
• wasm-bindgen
• worker bundle build
• generated wasm copy

Snapshots

When snapshots fail:

1. Inspect the actual diff.
2. Identify the upstream commit/change that caused the output change.
3. Explain why JS/CSS/runtime output changed and whether it follows upstream semantics.
4. Propose either code adaptation or snapshot update, then wait for user confirmation.
5. Update only affected snapshots when the change is expected and confirmed.
6. Do not bulk-update snapshots without explaining why the output changed.

Cargo.lock Conflicts

Do not blindly regenerate Cargo.lock.

First identify whether the conflicting side is:

• upstream dependency graph
• utoo fork dependency
• stale stash/local lockfile

If the user does not want the stash Cargo.lock during stash pop:

git checkout --ours Cargo.lock
git add Cargo.lock

Commit Policy

Submodule

Inside next.js, commit or amend actual submodule code changes.

Commit message should mention the upstream change that required the adaptation when known.

If a utoo patch commit becomes redundant because upstream now implements equivalent behavior, it can be dropped during the rebase. Before doing so, explicitly report:

• the local patch commit being dropped
• the upstream commit/change that supersedes it
• why the upstream implementation is equivalent or preferable
• any remaining difference, if one exists

Current repository

Commit separately when possible:

• submodule pointer updates
• local Rust API adaptations
• CI/toolchain updates
• wasm configuration updates
• snapshot updates

Do not include unrelated local files or generated artifacts.

Before committing, inspect:

git status --short
git diff --cached --stat
git diff --submodule=log -- next.js

Useful Commands

# Show submodule pointer change
git diff --submodule=log -- next.js

# Verify plugin feature path
cargo build --features plugin -p pack-napi --profile release-local

# Verify wasm package
cd packages/utoo-web
ut build:local