valuemelody Review Feature
Review the current uncommitted changes as a feature review.
Scope
- Focus only on feature completeness and product behavior.
- Ignore tests and test quality completely.
- Ignore style, formatting, naming, refactoring, and performance unless they directly break the feature.
Step 1: Inspect the current work
- Run
git status --short. - Review both staged and unstaged diffs.
- Read the changed files and any nearby code needed to understand the intended behavior.
- If the user provided extra context, use it to infer the expected feature scope.
- If there are no uncommitted changes, say so clearly and stop.
What to look for
- Missing frontend, backend, API, or data wiring
- Missing validation, authorization, persistence, schema, or route updates
- Missing loading, empty, success, or error states that break the feature flow
- Missing translations, generated artifacts, or docs only when they are required for the feature to ship
- Edge cases or regressions that make the feature incomplete for real users
Response format
- Start with findings only, ordered by severity
- For each finding, explain why it matters for feature behavior and cite file paths with line numbers
- Never mention tests, missing tests, or test quality
- If no feature-level gaps are found, say exactly:
No feature-level gaps found in the current uncommitted changes. - Add a short
Open questionssection only if needed