For Reviewers (+2)
For Reviewers
- Be specific: Point to exact text, not vague areas
- Be constructive: Offer solutions, not just problems
- Prioritize: Distinguish critical from nice-to-have
- Explain reasoning: Help author learn and decide
- Respect voice: Preserve author's style where appropriate
For Authors
- Consider all feedback: Even if not accepting
- Ask clarifying questions: Before dismissing suggestions
- Track decisions: Note why changes were accepted/rejected
- Thank reviewers: Acknowledge contribution
For Both
- Agree on process: Establish review expectations upfront
- Set timelines: Clear deadlines for each review round
- Use consistent tools: Same markup/format for all feedback
- Communicate changes: Notify when versions are ready