Create Issue Gate

Create Issue Gate

Overview

Create GitHub issues as the single tracking entrypoint for tasks, with a hard gate on acceptance criteria.

Core rule: no explicit, testable acceptance criteria from user => issue stays draft and execution is blocked.

When to Use

• You are starting a new implementation task and want a GitHub issue to be the required tracking entrypoint.
• The work must be blocked until the user provides explicit, testable acceptance criteria.
• You need to distinguish between draft, ready, and blocked work before execution begins.

Required Fields

Every issue must include these sections:

• Problem
• Goal
• Scope
• Non-Goals
• Acceptance Criteria
• Dependencies/Blockers
• Status (draft | ready | blocked | done)

Acceptance Criteria Gate

Acceptance criteria are valid only when they are testable and pass/fail checkable.

Examples:

• valid: "CreateCheckoutLambda-dev returns an openable third-party payment checkout URL"
• invalid: "fix checkout" / "improve UX" / "make it better"

If criteria are missing or non-testable:

• still create the issue
• set Status: draft
• add Execution Gate: blocked (missing valid acceptance criteria)
• do not move task to execution

Issue Creation Mode

Default mode is direct GitHub creation using gh issue create.

Use a body template like:

## Problem
<what is broken or missing>

## Goal
<what outcome is expected>

## Scope
- <in scope item>

## Non-Goals
- <out of scope item>

## Acceptance Criteria
- <explicit, testable criterion 1>

## Dependencies/Blockers
- <dependency or none>

## Status
draft|ready|blocked|done

## Execution Gate
allowed|blocked (<reason>)

Status Rules

• draft: missing/weak acceptance criteria or incomplete task definition
• ready: acceptance criteria are explicit and testable
• blocked: external dependency prevents progress
• done: acceptance criteria verified with evidence

Never mark an issue ready without valid acceptance criteria.

Handoff to Execution

Execution workflows (for example closed-loop-delivery) may start only when:

• issue status is ready
• execution gate is allowed

If issue is draft, stop and request user-provided acceptance criteria.