Winbda Decision Matrix
Overview
Creates structured decision matrices that objectively compare options using weighted criteria.
Workflow
Step 1: Define the Decision
- What are you deciding?
- Options: What are the 2-5 options?
- Criteria: What matters most? (cost, speed, quality, risk, etc.)
- Stakeholders: Who cares about this decision?
Step 2: Weight the Criteria
| Criteria | Weight (1-10) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| [Criteria 1] | [weight] | [reasoning] |
| [Criteria 2] | [weight] | [reasoning] |
Step 3: Score Each Option
| Criteria (Weight) | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|---|---|---|---|
| [C1] (×8) | [score/10] = [weighted] | [score] = [weighted] | [score] = [weighted] |
| [C2] (×6) | [score/10] = [weighted] | [score] = [weighted] | [score] = [weighted] |
| TOTAL | [sum] | [sum] | [sum] |
Step 4: Recommendation
## Recommendation: [Winner]
**Score**: [X] out of [max possible]
**Why this wins**: [2-3 sentences]
**Key tradeoffs**: [what you give up]
**Risk factors**: [what could go wrong]
**Dissenting view**: [argument for the runner-up]
Quality Checklist
- Criteria weighted before scoring
- Scores justified (not arbitrary)
- Winner explained with reasoning
- Tradeoffs acknowledged
- Dissenting view presented