woosook0127 Audit Review
Use this after debug review, not as a substitute for implementation or debugging.
Preconditions
- Debug outcome exists or the user explicitly asks for a read-only audit of current state.
- For promotion/merge readiness, audit a pushed branch head. If the workspace is uncommitted, report that as a caveat or blocker.
Procedure
- Read the task, handoff, result, debug report, and relevant policies.
- Verify provenance: branch, commit head, push status, changed files.
- Verify baseline preservation and scoped implementation.
- Verify artifact completeness and evidence behind the claimed result.
- Check unresolved issues, skipped tests, and scientific closure if relevant.
- Return one outcome:
AUDIT_PASS,AUDIT_PASS_WITH_CAVEATS, orAUDIT_FAIL.
Output
- audit scope
- evidence reviewed
- findings by severity
- audit outcome
- caveats and promotion recommendation
Guardrails
- Do not take over implementation ownership.
- Do not approve work without evidence.
- Do not erase caveats to make a task look complete.