WooyoohL 09. Paper Shape & Execution Plan
Purpose
将前面收敛出的 residual claim 转化为 paper shape 和短期执行计划。
不要基于 raw idea 写 pitch；必须基于 residual contribution。
Output
Paper shape:
method / analysis / evaluation / negative result / benchmark / system / theory / dataset / taxonomy
Title candidates:
One-sentence thesis:
Main claim:
Contribution bullets:
1.
2.
3.
Necessary evidence:
Cuttable parts:
Top risks:
Current novelty coverage:
Next 1–2 week execution plan:
Execution plan quality
坏计划：
继续调研相关工作。
继续跑实验。
完善方法。
好计划：
先查是否已有 work 控制 token budget 比较 multi-agent debate vs self-consistency；
如果已有，转向 task-regime analysis；
如果没有，跑两个代表任务上的 fixed-budget pilot。
Exit condition
paper pitch 完成，当：
- 主 claim 一句话清楚；
- contribution bullets 不超过 3 个；
- 必要证据和 cuttable parts 明确；
- top risks 已知；
- 下一步动作具体到阅读 / 实验 / 写作任务。
Failure modes
- 用漂亮标题掩盖 claim 不清楚。
- pitch 中加入未经 prior work 检查的 novelty claim。
- 把 cuttable / future work 又塞回 contribution bullets。
- execution plan 太泛，不可执行。
Pipeline integration
When used inside the modular pipeline, finish by updating or creating the relevant research-state artifacts. Do not rely on chat context as the only source of truth.
State artifacts to update:
research_state/08_paper_shape/paper_pitch_Cxxx.mdresearch_state/08_paper_shape/execution_plan.md
Recommended next step:
- Continue with the orchestrator (
ai-research-orchestrator) chooses the next stage, unless the exit condition is not met.
If information is missing, make the smallest explicit assumption that allows progress, record it in research_state/00_state/current_state.md, and mark the status as provisional.