Comfyui Workflow Guardian

ComfyUI Workflow Guardian

Use this skill to work on ComfyUI like an infrastructure and workflow engineer, not like an improvising prompt tweaker.

Core Rules

• Back up the target workflow before editing it.
• Change only the workflow the user explicitly names. Do not sync other workflows unless asked.
• Inspect runtime failures before editing the workflow. A dead backend is not a workflow bug.
• Prefer one precise change over many speculative changes.
• Keep optional modules behind switches so they do not add cost when disabled.
• Preserve working post-processing sections unless the user explicitly wants them changed.
• Prefer validated architecture rules over folklore or one-off community claims.

Workflow

1. Classify the task

Classify the request before touching files:

• Runtime failure: startup crash, queue crash, Failed to fetch, access violation, provider error
• Structure failure: broken links, missing files, overlapping nodes/groups, unreadable layout
• Quality failure: identity drift, anatomy defects, artifacts, color shifts, over-smoothing
• Performance failure: generation too slow, unnecessary modules active, too many second-pass steps
• Architecture change: adding or comparing LoRAs, identity modules, refiners, control branches

2. Read the right reference file

• Ask the user for the active ComfyUI root and workflow path; never assume workstation-specific locations.
• Read references/runtime-performance.md for crashes, access violations, performance regressions, or backend instability.
• Read references/identity-modules.md for BFS, PuLID, LanPaint-style face transfer, or identity-preservation tasks.
• Read references/workflow-editing-checklist.md before editing workflow JSON.

3. Validate before editing

Run the bundled checker on the target workflow:

python scripts/check_comfyui_workflow.py "C:\path\to\workflow.json" --comfy-root "C:\path\to\ComfyUI"

Use it before and after edits. Treat these as hard failures until explained:

• missing node references
• missing model or LoRA files
• overlapping nodes
• overlapping groups

4. Apply architecture rules

Follow these stable ordering rules unless source documentation for a specific module contradicts them:

• Put the base model loader first.
• Put general LoRAs that shape the base image before the main sampler.
• Put identity model layers after the general LoRA chain when they modify the final model directly.
• Put second-pass face-transfer or inpainting systems after the base image is generated.
• Put detail or sharpening passes after identity transfer, not before.
• Keep manual size overrides, CFG, and quality toggles in a compact quick-access area, but leave original nodes in place if the workflow already depends on them.

5. Change conservatively

• Tighten one branch at a time.
• If a post-pass copies unwanted props, hands, or expressions, reduce what that pass is allowed to transfer instead of raising its strength blindly.
• If identity is weak, test the identity modules separately before combining them.
• If performance is poor, reduce second-pass cost before degrading the main generation stage.
• Do not switch models, precision modes, or providers without evidence that the current setting is the cause.

6. Validate after editing

After edits:

• run the workflow checker again
• confirm the target files exist on disk
• confirm the launcher and runtime still start
• confirm the active workflow still loads cleanly
• summarize only the actual changes, default values, and residual risks

Operating Defaults

Use these defaults when the user does not specify otherwise:

• Keep the user's main workflow as the only edit target.
• Keep the runtime conservative and stable on Windows.
• Treat second-pass identity transfer as optional and isolated.
• Favor clean, non-overlapping layout and short notes over decorative complexity.
• Favor explicit validation over guesswork.

Output Requirements

When finishing a task with this skill:

• name the exact files changed
• name the critical node or runtime settings changed
• state what was validated
• state what remains uncertain