assess-removability
Purpose
Estimate whether a constraint can be removed or relaxed, at what cost, and with which residual risks.
Input contract
required: [constraint_record, dependency_map, removal_options, cost_model]
optional: [time_horizon, safety_limits, stakeholder_requirements]
constraints: [each option states feasibility, cost units, dependencies, and residual risk]
Procedure
- Trace the constraint to dependent claims, processes, and safety conditions.
- Generate removal or relaxation options and estimate direct cost, delay, dependency changes, and residual risk.
- Test each option against non-negotiable boundaries and identify the cheapest feasible relaxation.
- Emit removability class, cost/risk profile, and a reversible trial where one exists.
Output contract
produces: [removability_assessment, option_comparison, residual_risks, recommended_trial]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]
Quality gates
- A-class gate: declared universe = all identified constraints and removal options; numerator = options with dependency, cost, and residual-risk evidence; batch increment = one option assessed; stopping reason = all options assessed or a feasible dominant option is established; source references = dependency, cost, and risk IDs; direction/threshold reason = removability improves only when dependency burden and residual risk decrease without violating hard boundaries.
- A removal claim must include at least one dependency, one cost, and one residual risk.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not label a constraint removable because it is inconvenient. If removal changes the target construct, report a scope change instead.
Provenance map
- resolved: removability-assessment
1---2name: assess-removability3description: "Estimate whether and at what cost a constraint can be removed or relaxed."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/yogsoth-ai/assess-removability6---78# assess-removability9## Purpose10Estimate whether a constraint can be removed or relaxed, at what cost, and with which residual risks.11## Input contract12```yaml13required: [constraint_record, dependency_map, removal_options, cost_model]14optional: [time_horizon, safety_limits, stakeholder_requirements]15constraints: [each option states feasibility, cost units, dependencies, and residual risk]16```17## Procedure181. Trace the constraint to dependent claims, processes, and safety conditions.192. Generate removal or relaxation options and estimate direct cost, delay, dependency changes, and residual risk.203. Test each option against non-negotiable boundaries and identify the cheapest feasible relaxation.214. Emit removability class, cost/risk profile, and a reversible trial where one exists.22## Output contract23```yaml24produces: [removability_assessment, option_comparison, residual_risks, recommended_trial]25delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]26```27## Quality gates28- A-class gate: declared universe = all identified constraints and removal options; numerator = options with dependency, cost, and residual-risk evidence; batch increment = one option assessed; stopping reason = all options assessed or a feasible dominant option is established; source references = dependency, cost, and risk IDs; direction/threshold reason = removability improves only when dependency burden and residual risk decrease without violating hard boundaries.29- A removal claim must include at least one dependency, one cost, and one residual risk.30## Failure and counterexamples31Do not label a constraint removable because it is inconvenient. If removal changes the target construct, report a scope change instead.32## Provenance map33- resolved: removability-assessment