define-evidence-protocol
Purpose
Define research questions, eligible evidence scope, query concepts, inclusion/exclusion rules, provenance requirements, and stopping evidence.
Input contract
required: [research_question, evidence_scope, inclusion_rules]
optional: [exclusion_rules, query_concepts, quality_rubric, stopping_policy]
constraints: [eligible universe, provenance fields, and stopping evidence must be explicit]
Procedure
- State the question, target population or domain, comparison, outcomes, and time boundaries.
- Define eligible evidence, exclusion rules, source-independence requirements, and extraction fields.
- Specify batch boundaries, novelty dimensions, and relative stopping evidence.
- Record unresolved scope choices before acquisition begins.
If the protocol fixes inclusion, exclusion, and stopping rules, consider select-seed-evidence as the next tactic.
Output contract
produces: [evidence_protocol, eligible_universe, query_concepts, screening_rules, provenance_requirements, stopping_evidence]
delta_fields: [decisions, assumption_updates, uncertainties, open_questions]
Quality gates
- The eligible universe and exclusion rules are operational.
- Stopping evidence names numerator, denominator, batch increment, source references, direction, threshold, and rationale when relative quantities apply.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not use provider names as a protocol, and do not declare coverage from search volume without a defined eligible universe.
Provenance map
resolved: define-search-protocol
resolved: inclusion-criteria-design
1---2name: define-evidence-protocol3description: "Define research questions, evidence scope, queries/concepts, inclusion/exclusion rules, provenance requirements, and stopping evidence for an acquisition task."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/yogsoth-ai/define-evidence-protocol6---78# define-evidence-protocol910## Purpose1112Define research questions, eligible evidence scope, query concepts, inclusion/exclusion rules, provenance requirements, and stopping evidence.1314## Input contract1516```yaml17required: [research_question, evidence_scope, inclusion_rules]18optional: [exclusion_rules, query_concepts, quality_rubric, stopping_policy]19constraints: [eligible universe, provenance fields, and stopping evidence must be explicit]20```2122## Procedure23241. State the question, target population or domain, comparison, outcomes, and time boundaries.252. Define eligible evidence, exclusion rules, source-independence requirements, and extraction fields.263. Specify batch boundaries, novelty dimensions, and relative stopping evidence.274. Record unresolved scope choices before acquisition begins.2829If the protocol fixes inclusion, exclusion, and stopping rules, consider `select-seed-evidence` as the next tactic.3031## Output contract3233```yaml34produces: [evidence_protocol, eligible_universe, query_concepts, screening_rules, provenance_requirements, stopping_evidence]35delta_fields: [decisions, assumption_updates, uncertainties, open_questions]36```3738## Quality gates3940- The eligible universe and exclusion rules are operational.41- Stopping evidence names numerator, denominator, batch increment, source references, direction, threshold, and rationale when relative quantities apply.4243## Failure and counterexamples4445Do not use provider names as a protocol, and do not declare coverage from search volume without a defined eligible universe.4647## Provenance map4849- `resolved: define-search-protocol`50- `resolved: inclusion-criteria-design`