design-study-inclusion
Purpose
Define study inclusion and exclusion criteria with explicit rules for borderline cases.
Input contract
required: [research_question, eligible_population, study_scope]
optional: [outcome_rules, design_rules, date_language_limits]
constraints: [criteria must be observable from source records]
Procedure
- Translate the question into population, intervention/exposure, comparator, outcome, design, and context criteria.
- Define exclusion reasons and precedence for overlapping rules.
- Specify borderline-case adjudication and missing-information handling.
- Test criteria against representative included, excluded, and ambiguous records.
If eligible designs, populations, interventions, and outcomes are fixed, consider plan-effect-size as the next tactic.
Output contract
produces: [inclusion_criteria, exclusion_reasons, borderline_rules, pilot_adjudications]
delta_fields: [decisions, assumption_updates, uncertainties, open_questions]
Quality gates
- Criteria are applicable without knowing the study result.
- Each exclusion has one primary reason.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not make inclusion depend on favorable findings or exclude a study solely because metadata are incomplete when the design remains eligible.
Provenance map
resolved: inclusion-criteria-design
