yogsoth-ai Disagreement Mapping
Map the structure of disagreement rather than forcing convergence. Collect diverse judgments, identify natural clusters of opinion, extract the core arguments supporting each cluster, and produce a visual map of the disagreement topology.
Stages
- Collect — Run
judgment-collectionto gather positions and reasoning from all perspectives - Cluster — Run
cluster-analysisto identify natural groupings of similar positions - Extract — Run
argument-extractionfor each cluster to surface core arguments - Visualize — Run
disagreement-visualizationto produce the disagreement map
Available SOPs
| SOP | Role in Tactic |
|---|---|
| judgment-collection | Gather positions with reasoning from all perspectives |
| cluster-analysis | Identify natural opinion clusters and characterize them |
| argument-extraction | Extract and steel-man core arguments for each cluster |
| disagreement-visualization | Produce structured map of clusters, arguments, and fault lines |
Execution Guidance
- Collect BOTH positions AND reasoning (not just ratings)
- Clustering should be based on reasoning similarity, not just position proximity
- Each cluster's arguments should be steel-manned (strongest possible version)
- Visualization should show: cluster sizes, key arguments, fault lines between clusters
- Identify whether disagreements are empirical, value-based, or definitional
Minimum Yield
- Disagreement clusters (identified clusters with characterization)
- Core arguments per cluster (core arguments per cluster, steel-manned)
- Visualization (disagreement map showing topology and fault lines)
Available SOPs
Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.
| SOP | When to use |
|---|---|
| argument-extraction | Extract and steel-man the core arguments supporting a given opinion cluster. |
| cluster-analysis | Identify natural opinion clusters from collected judgments and characterize each cluster. |
| disagreement-visualization | Produce a structured disagreement map showing clusters, arguments, and fault lines. |
| judgment-collection | Collect independent judgments from all perspectives on a given question. |