document-counterclaim
Purpose
Document a credible counterclaim, its supporting basis, scope, and implications for the focal claim.
Input contract
required: [focal_claim, counterclaim, evidence_records]
optional: [argument_context, boundary_conditions, response_options]
constraints: [counterclaim must be stated in its strongest evidence-supported form]
Procedure
- State the counterclaim and the proposition it challenges.
- Attach supporting evidence, assumptions, and boundary conditions.
- Compare explanatory coverage, conflicts, and unresolved evidence.
- Record implications, possible rebuttals, and residual uncertainty.
Output contract
produces: [counterclaim_record, support_map, assumption_register, implication_set, rebuttal_questions]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, open_questions]
Quality gates
- Counterclaim is not a caricature of the opposing position.
- Evidence and scope are explicit.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not dismiss a counterclaim because it is inconvenient or confuse disagreement with refutation.
Provenance map
resolved: document-counterclaim
