evaluate-falsifiability
Purpose
Evaluate whether a claim or hypothesis exposes observations that could count against it.
Input contract
required: [claim, prediction_set, observation_domain]
optional: [auxiliary_assumptions, measurement_limits]
constraints: [falsifying conditions must be observable within the declared domain]
Procedure
- Translate the claim into testable predictions and boundary conditions.
- Identify observations that would contradict the claim under its assumptions.
- Check whether those observations are measurable and independent of the claim's definition.
- Classify falsifiability and list needed operationalization.
Output contract
produces: [falsifiability_assessment, falsifying_observations, operationalization_gaps, assumption_dependencies]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, open_questions]
Quality gates
- At least one non-vacuous potential counter-observation is explicit for a falsifiable claim.
- Auxiliary assumptions are separated from the core claim.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not call a claim falsifiable merely because it can be criticized rhetorically.
Provenance map
resolved: evaluate-falsifiability
