falsification-first-audit
Purpose
Convert a sharp claim into the cheapest decisive falsification program and return BROKEN, CORROBORATED, or UNFALSIFIABLE.
Input contract
mode_contracts:
sharp-claim: &falsification_input
required: [claim, scope, available_evidence]
optional: [mechanism, candidate_tests]
constraints: [claim_must_expose_observable_consequences_and_boundary_conditions]
truthseeking-debate: *falsification_input
truthseeking-red-team: *falsification_input
Execution protocol
Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.
- You MUST load skill
sharpen-falsifiable-claimto sharpen the claim. You MUST load skillsurface-assumptionsto expose its assumptions. - You MUST load skill
design-falsification-testto design the cheapest decisive falsification test. - You MUST load skill
execute-probeto execute the most informative probe. - You MUST load skill
classify-falsification-verdictto classify only the permitted truth-seeking verdict. If the claim depends on a structural mapping, consideraudit-structural-equivalence. If the test or oracle may be circular, consideraudit-validator-independence. If agreement among paths may not be independent, consideraudit-convergence-independence. If simplicity is carrying the claim, consideraudit-explanatory-compression. If survival is confined to an uncertain region, considermap-validity-envelope. Deviation: if no legitimate falsifier can be specified or reached, stop with UNFALSIFIABLE; do not substitute a resilience score.
Output contract
mode_contracts:
sharp-claim:
produces: [claim_falsifiability, refutation_condition, attacks_attempted, outcome_bucket, refutation_or_surviving_forbidden_content, honest_residue]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
truthseeking-debate:
produces: [most_falsifiable_form, committed_refuter, cross_examination_findings, attack_severity, outcome_bucket, refutation_or_forbidden_content]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
truthseeking-red-team:
produces: [claim_load_rank, assumption_classification, refutation_condition, refutation_attempt, outcome_bucket, framing_risk_brief]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
Thresholds and quality gates
- Verdict is BROKEN only when a legitimate falsifier succeeds; CORROBORATED only after an adequate test fails to falsify; otherwise UNFALSIFIABLE.
- Preserve scope, power/precision assumptions, and probe provenance.
Failure and counterexamples
Post-hoc accommodation, unfalsifiable wording, or an unreachable test cannot support CORROBORATED.
Provenance map
- resolved: falsification-first-stress-test
- resolved: adversarial-debate-truthseeking
- resolved: red-team-truthseeking
Preserved source criteria ledger
| source | source line | kind | source criterion |
|---|---|---|---|
| v4 architecture | node desc | textual | Return only BROKEN, CORROBORATED, or UNFALSIFIABLE; no resilience score. |
Context checkpoint / Delta notes
Append sharpened claim, test design, probe result, verdict, and unresolved falsifier questions.
Mode branches
sharp-claim: direct falsification program.truthseeking-debate: combine with adversarial exchange while preserving verdict semantics.truthseeking-red-team: use attack probes while preserving verdict semantics.
