identify-load-bearing-factors
Purpose
Identify factors or assumptions whose change most strongly controls the conclusion.
Input contract
required: [conclusion, factor_or_assumption_set, perturbation_evidence]
optional: [necessity_sufficiency_results, uncertainty_contributions, critical_path]
constraints: [load-bearing status is tied to observed or reasoned conclusion change; preserve factor identity]
Procedure
- Assemble ablation, necessity/sufficiency, fragility, and uncertainty evidence.
- Compare conclusion changes attributable to each factor.
- Classify factors as necessary, sufficient, jointly necessary, or decorative where supported.
- Rank load-bearing factors and state the evidence gap for each uncertain ranking.
Output contract
produces: [load_bearing_register, necessity_sufficiency_map, fragility_ranking, evidence_gaps]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, decisions, uncertainties]
Quality gates
- Every factor receives a role classification and evidence-backed importance assessment.
- Fragility severity and alternative credibility are reported separately.
- EVPI or uncertainty-contribution results retain the caller's units and are not treated as causal proof.
Parameterization
The caller must provide conclusion schema, factor/assumption list, perturbation results, classification ontology, importance metric, and uncertainty representation.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject a load-bearing claim based only on correlation, an untested factor, or a perturbation that changes multiple undeclared inputs.
Provenance map
- resolved: stress-test/load-bearing-identification
- resolved: deep-insight/fragility-flagging
- resolved: deep-insight/critical-path-identification
Preserved source criteria ledger
No numeric source gate was present in the resolved source nodes; the role and evidence requirements above preserve their qualitative constraints.
