identify-theory
Purpose
Identify the theory or theoretical family that best organizes a claim, mechanism, or observed regularity.
Input contract
required: [claim_or_mechanism, construct_definitions, evidence_context]
optional: [candidate_theories, domain_scope]
constraints: [theory identification requires construct and mechanism correspondence]
Procedure
- Extract constructs, relations, boundary conditions, and explanatory target.
- Compare candidate theories by construct mapping and predicted relations.
- Record supporting, conflicting, and missing evidence for each mapping.
- State the selected theory or unresolved alternatives with scope limits.
Output contract
produces: [theory_candidates, construct_mapping, relation_mapping, theory_assessment, scope_limits]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, decisions, open_questions]
Quality gates
- Mapping is based on definitions and relations, not name similarity.
- Boundary conditions are retained.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not infer theoretical identity from shared vocabulary or force a theory when only a local mechanism is supported.
Provenance map
resolved: identify-theory
