Importance Scoring
Assess the academic and practical importance of a research gap, output a 1-5 score with rationale.
HARD-GATE
Pipeline
- Precondition check: verify input GapRecord completeness; confirm the domain field is valid
- Domain impact assessment: judge how much this gap affects the core problems of its field (1-5); reference: whether it blocks the field's progress, whether it is repeatedly mentioned across multiple papers
- Theoretical contribution assessment: judge the contribution that filling this gap makes to the theoretical system (1-5); reference: whether it challenges the existing paradigm, whether it can unify fragmented theories
- Practical value assessment: judge the real-world application value of filling this gap (1-5); reference: size of the benefiting population, implementability, industry/policy impact
- Composite score: weighted average of the three dimensions (domain impact 40%, theoretical contribution 30%, practical value 30%), to one decimal place
- Output: return the ImportanceScore object
Output Format
{
"gap_id": "gap_001",
"dimension_scores": {
"domain_impact": { "score": 4, "rationale": "..." },
"theoretical_contribution": { "score": 3, "rationale": "..." },
"practical_value": { "score": 4, "rationale": "..." }
},
"composite_score": 3.7,
"overall_rationale": "Overall rationale (2-4 sentences)"
}
