Inductive Hypothesis Generation
Induce and distill hypotheses from data/observations: in domains with theoretical gaps or insufficient theory, distill regularities from empirical patterns and cautiously generalize them into testable propositions.
When to Use
- The domain lacks mature theory but has accumulated abundant empirical observations or data patterns
- The research gap appears as "a recurring phenomenon with no systematic explanation yet"
- The goal is to distill regularities from data, laying a foundation for subsequent theory construction
- An exploratory research stage where it is not yet clear which variables matter
Not applicable: domains that already have a clear theoretical framework → use deductive-hypothesis-generation instead.
Thinking Framework
Observe patterns → Extract regularity → Generalize cautiously → Formulate testable claim
The core logic of induction:
- Observe patterns: systematically organize patterns that recur across existing observations, data, and cases (not single anomalies)
- Extract regularity: identify the regularity behind the patterns — under what conditions it appears, under what conditions it does not
- Generalize cautiously: cautiously generalize the regularity from the specific samples — make the boundary of generalization explicit, do not over-extrapolate
- Formulate testable claim: turn the generalized regularity into a proposition that can be tested on new samples
The core risk of induction: over-generalization (jumping from a limited sample to a universal law). Each inductive hypothesis must make explicit:
- Which samples the observations come from (sample characteristics, source, time range)
- Which population it generalizes to (the boundary of generalization scope)
- What evidence would limit or refute the generalization
Budget Gate
| Tier | Pattern coverage | Regularity extraction | Hypothesis yield | Generalization boundary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | ≥3 independent observation patterns | ≥2 regularities | ≥2 structured hypotheses | Each hypothesis specifies its sample source |
| M | ≥5 independent observation patterns | ≥3 regularities | ≥3 structured hypotheses | Generalization boundary + falsification scenario |
| L | ≥8 independent observation patterns | ≥5 regularities | ≥4 structured hypotheses | Complete generalization boundary + comparison of competing regularities |
Default Reference Flow
- Invoke the
anomaly-characterizationSOP: systematically organize the patterns in existing observations/data (including frequency, conditions, exceptions) - Invoke the
explanation-generationSOP (via theanomaly-driven-abductiontactic): generate candidate regularity explanations for each pattern - Invoke the
variable-identificationSOP: turn the constructs in the regularities into operationalizable variables - Invoke the
relationship-specificationSOP: specify the directional relationships between variables (including moderating conditions) - Invoke the
falsifiability-checkSOP (via thefalsifiability-audittactic): generate a falsification scenario + generalization boundary for each hypothesis
context-checkpoint
Record after each round:
- The list of organized observation patterns (pattern description, source, frequency of occurrence)
- The list of extracted regularities (regularity statement, supporting patterns, exceptions)
- The current draft hypothesis set (including generalization-boundary statements)
- Falsifiability status + over-generalization risk assessment
Available Tactics
Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.
| Tactic | When to use |
|---|---|
| anomaly-driven-abduction | Tactic: Inductive/abductive path — describe anomalous phenomena, generate candidate explanations, rank by plausibility |
| falsifiability-audit | Tactic: hypothesis quality assurance — check falsifiability, repair failing hypotheses, complete operationalization and boundary-condition specification |
Available SOPs
Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.
| SOP | When to use |
|---|---|
| hypothesis-formation-variable-identification | SOP: identify variables and their roles within a hypothesis |
| relationship-specification | SOP: specify the direction and form of relationships between variables |
