problem-reframing
Purpose
Change a limiting problem representation through frame escape, perspective rotation, polarity, or abstraction/scope shifts.
Input contract
mode_contracts:
dominant-frame-escape: &reframing_input
required: [problem_statement, current_frame]
optional: [stakeholders, assumptions]
constraints: [each_reframe_must_state_what_changed_and_what_remains_invariant]
perspective-shift: *reframing_input
stakeholder/worldview: *reframing_input
polarity: *reframing_input
abstraction-scope: *reframing_input
Execution protocol
Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.
- Select the reframe mode that matches the declared failure in the current frame.
- Execute the mode-specific operations below without deleting the original frame or its evidence.
- Record the transformed frame, derived consequences, invariants, and unresolved disagreement.
If a reframed question is ready to generate testable explanations, consider
formulate-hypotheses. If opposing frames require a structured exchange, adversarial-deliberation may be the better next tactic.
Deviation: mode selects a subset, but every omitted operation must be justified by the declared reframe mode and input.
Mode branches
dominant-frame-escape: identify and challenge the frame governing the current question. You MUST load skill identify-dominant-frame to identify that frame. You MUST load skill generate-provocation to challenge it. You MUST load skill derive-consequences to trace the resulting consequences. You MUST load skill appreciative-reframe to retain generative strengths while escaping the dominant frame.
perspective-shift: rotate explicit reviewer, practitioner, theorist, time, or novice views. You MUST load skill construct-perspective-set to construct the explicit views. You MUST load skill rotate-perspective to rotate them. You MUST load skill map-disagreement to retain their substantive disagreements.
stakeholder/worldview: reframe around stakeholder interests and lived assumptions. You MUST load skill construct-perspective-set to construct stakeholder worldviews. You MUST load skill rotate-perspective to apply each worldview. You MUST load skill assess-problem-wickedness to assess conflicts that prevent a single stable frame. You MUST load skill map-disagreement to preserve unresolved interests.
polarity: expose productive opposition and map its consequences. You MUST load skill map-productive-polarity to map the opposing poles. You MUST load skill derive-consequences to derive their consequences.
abstraction-scope: move up/down the abstraction or scope ladder and preserve invariants. You MUST load skill adjust-abstraction-scope to move the frame while preserving declared invariants.
Output contract
mode_contracts:
dominant-frame-escape:
produces: [dominant_frame, reframe_set, consequence_map]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]
perspective-shift:
produces: [reframe_set, perspective_map, consequence_map]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]
stakeholder/worldview:
produces: [reframe_set, perspective_map]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]
polarity:
produces: [reframe_set, consequence_map, polarity_map]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]
abstraction-scope:
produces: [dominant_frame, reframe_set]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]
Thresholds and quality gates
- B: at least two materially distinct frames are recorded; invariants, changed assumptions, and downstream consequences are explicit.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject cosmetic wording changes, perspective lists without consequence changes, and reframes that erase the original decision target.
Provenance map
problem-reformulation, dominant-idea-escape, multi-perspective-reframing, dialectical-reformulation, question-reformulation, creative-ideation/perspective-forcing, six-thinking-hats, role-storming, perspective-rotation, synectics/personal-analogy, Pass8/force-perspective-shift: resolved/concept per exact lookup.
- Status:
problem-reformulation, dominant-idea-escape, multi-perspective-reframing, dialectical-reformulation, question-reformulation, creative-ideation/perspective-forcing, synectics/personal-analogy resolved; six-thinking-hats, role-storming, perspective-rotation, Pass8/force-perspective-shift concept.
Preserved source criteria ledger
- Preserve Six Hats, synectics/personal analogy, dialectical polarity, dominant-frame escape, and abstraction/scope shifts.
Context checkpoint / Delta notes
Append frame changes, perspective consequences, polarity tensions, and selected reframe.
1---2name: problem-reframing3description: "Change the problem representation when the current frame is limiting: dominant-frame escape, stakeholder/worldview rotation, forced perspective shifts, dialectical/polarity reframing, or abstraction/scope shifts."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/yogsoth-ai/problem-reframing6---78# problem-reframing9## Purpose10Change a limiting problem representation through frame escape, perspective rotation, polarity, or abstraction/scope shifts.11## Input contract12```yaml13mode_contracts:14 dominant-frame-escape: &reframing_input15 required: [problem_statement, current_frame]16 optional: [stakeholders, assumptions]17 constraints: [each_reframe_must_state_what_changed_and_what_remains_invariant]18 perspective-shift: *reframing_input19 stakeholder/worldview: *reframing_input20 polarity: *reframing_input21 abstraction-scope: *reframing_input22```23## Execution protocol24Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.25261. Select the reframe mode that matches the declared failure in the current frame.272. Execute the mode-specific operations below without deleting the original frame or its evidence.283. Record the transformed frame, derived consequences, invariants, and unresolved disagreement.29 If a reframed question is ready to generate testable explanations, consider `formulate-hypotheses`. If opposing frames require a structured exchange, `adversarial-deliberation` may be the better next tactic.30Deviation: mode selects a subset, but every omitted operation must be justified by the declared reframe mode and input.31## Mode branches32- `dominant-frame-escape`: identify and challenge the frame governing the current question. You MUST load skill `identify-dominant-frame` to identify that frame. You MUST load skill `generate-provocation` to challenge it. You MUST load skill `derive-consequences` to trace the resulting consequences. You MUST load skill `appreciative-reframe` to retain generative strengths while escaping the dominant frame.33- `perspective-shift`: rotate explicit reviewer, practitioner, theorist, time, or novice views. You MUST load skill `construct-perspective-set` to construct the explicit views. You MUST load skill `rotate-perspective` to rotate them. You MUST load skill `map-disagreement` to retain their substantive disagreements.34- `stakeholder/worldview`: reframe around stakeholder interests and lived assumptions. You MUST load skill `construct-perspective-set` to construct stakeholder worldviews. You MUST load skill `rotate-perspective` to apply each worldview. You MUST load skill `assess-problem-wickedness` to assess conflicts that prevent a single stable frame. You MUST load skill `map-disagreement` to preserve unresolved interests.35- `polarity`: expose productive opposition and map its consequences. You MUST load skill `map-productive-polarity` to map the opposing poles. You MUST load skill `derive-consequences` to derive their consequences.36- `abstraction-scope`: move up/down the abstraction or scope ladder and preserve invariants. You MUST load skill `adjust-abstraction-scope` to move the frame while preserving declared invariants.37## Output contract38```yaml39mode_contracts:40 dominant-frame-escape:41 produces: [dominant_frame, reframe_set, consequence_map]42 delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]43 perspective-shift:44 produces: [reframe_set, perspective_map, consequence_map]45 delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]46 stakeholder/worldview:47 produces: [reframe_set, perspective_map]48 delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]49 polarity:50 produces: [reframe_set, consequence_map, polarity_map]51 delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]52 abstraction-scope:53 produces: [dominant_frame, reframe_set]54 delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, assumption_updates, decisions, open_questions, recommended_jumps]55```56## Thresholds and quality gates57- B: at least two materially distinct frames are recorded; invariants, changed assumptions, and downstream consequences are explicit.58## Failure and counterexamples59Reject cosmetic wording changes, perspective lists without consequence changes, and reframes that erase the original decision target.60## Provenance map61- `problem-reformulation`, `dominant-idea-escape`, `multi-perspective-reframing`, `dialectical-reformulation`, `question-reformulation`, `creative-ideation/perspective-forcing`, `six-thinking-hats`, `role-storming`, `perspective-rotation`, `synectics/personal-analogy`, `Pass8/force-perspective-shift`: resolved/concept per exact lookup.62- Status: `problem-reformulation`, `dominant-idea-escape`, `multi-perspective-reframing`, `dialectical-reformulation`, `question-reformulation`, `creative-ideation/perspective-forcing`, `synectics/personal-analogy` resolved; `six-thinking-hats`, `role-storming`, `perspective-rotation`, `Pass8/force-perspective-shift` concept.63## Preserved source criteria ledger64- Preserve Six Hats, synectics/personal analogy, dialectical polarity, dominant-frame escape, and abstraction/scope shifts.65## Context checkpoint / Delta notes66Append frame changes, perspective consequences, polarity tensions, and selected reframe.