refine-claim
Purpose
Repair a claim by narrowing scope, adding a lemma, or decomposing it while preserving explanatory power.
Input contract
required: [claim, failure_or_counterexample, supporting_evidence]
optional: [scope_options, mechanism]
constraints: [every repair must state what was narrowed or added]
Procedure
- Identify the failed commitment.
- Generate scope, lemma, or decomposition repairs.
- Select a repair and record retained explanatory content.
Output contract
produces: [refined_claim, repair_rationale, retained_scope, lost_commitments]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
Quality gates
- Repair cannot silently exclude a counterexample without a principled boundary.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not relabel an unsupported claim as refined.
Provenance map
- resolved: claim-refinement
- resolved: monster-barring-attempt
