yogsoth-ai name: reproducibility-checklist-audit description: Assess paper completeness against ML Reproducibility Checklist execution: subagent prompt: ./prompt.md input: paper_content used-by: baseline-establishment
Reproducibility Checklist Audit
Purpose
Evaluate a paper against the standard ML Reproducibility Checklist (as used by NeurIPS, ICML, ICLR). Produces a structured assessment of what information is present, what is missing, and an overall reproducibility score.
Input Schema
| Field | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| paper_content | string | Full paper text (markdown format) |
Output Schema
{
"paper_title": "string",
"checklist": {
"model_architecture": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"training_procedure": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"hyperparameters": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"hyperparameter_search": {"present": false, "details": "string"},
"datasets": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"data_preprocessing": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"evaluation_metrics": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"error_bars_or_confidence": {"present": false, "details": "string"},
"number_of_runs": {"present": false, "details": "string"},
"compute_resources": {"present": false, "details": "string"},
"code_availability": {"present": true, "details": "string"},
"random_seeds": {"present": false, "details": "string"}
},
"overall_score": 0.0,
"critical_gaps": ["string"],
"reproducibility_risk": "low|medium|high|critical"
}