Rhetorical Structure Quality

(Proposal, unverified) Judge whether argumentative relations between unit-classification's rhetorical labels actually hold in a paper (e.g. is an AIM label adequately substantiated by BACKGROUND labels) — a second-order quality judgment over already-classified units, not raw text. Use this after unit-classification has labeled a paper's units with a rhetorical/argumentative label set, when the user wants to know if the paper's argument structure is actually sound, not just what role each sentence plays.

yogsoth-ai 7bab89f 2 files · 3.2 KB Updated

File contents

Rhetorical Structure Quality (Proposal)

Second-order SOP: judges whether rhetorical/argumentative labels (from unit-classification) actually substantiate each other, e.g. AIM vs BACKGROUND. Fills a gap in the evaluative-stance × content-layer matrix (quality-judgment × argumentative-rhetorical-role) that no verified method covers — this is a design proposal, not a transcription of an established methodology.

Execution

Subagent — spawned via spawn-agent skill.

Proposal Status — Read Before Modifying

This SOP has no primary-source precedent (unlike CoreSC/AZ, which it consumes labels from). Its description explicitly says "(Proposal, unverified)" so it is never triggered with the same implied confidence as a verified method. Do not remove that qualifier from the description without re-validating the method against real usage first.

Available SOPs

SOP When to use
spawn-agent Spawn a customized CC subagent with full MCP tool access.

yogsoth-ai/paper-reading/tree/main/skills/rhetorical-structure-quality commit 7bab89fcdc

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add yogsoth-ai/rhetorical-structure-quality