robustness-analysis
Purpose
Generate plausible model variants and test whether conclusions converge across assumptions and model choices.
Input contract
required: [base_model, conclusion, load_bearing_assumptions]
optional: [evidence, alternative_models, sensitivity_dimensions]
constraints: [variants must preserve the declared target question]
Execution protocol
Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.
- You MUST load skill
surface-assumptionsto surface assumptions. - You MUST load skill
generate-alternative-modelto generate plausible alternatives. - You MUST load skill
assess-sensitivityto compare sensitivity across variants. - You MUST load skill
identify-load-bearing-factorsto identify load-bearing factors. - You MUST load skill
analyze-scaling-regimeto check scaling regimes. If the result needs explicit validity boundaries, considermap-validity-envelope. If apparent agreement may reuse evidence or priors, consideraudit-convergence-independence. Deviation: omit scaling analysis only when the model has no scale variable; document the reason.
Output contract
produces: [model_variant_set, convergence_assessment, fragility_flags, load_bearing_factors]
delta_fields: [findings, hypothesis_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
Thresholds and quality gates
- B: at least two plausible variants are compared; conclusion changes, invariants, and fragility drivers are explicit.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not call a conclusion robust when all variants share the same unchallenged assumption.
Provenance map
robustness-testing,multi-model-convergence,alternative-model-generation,convergence-assessment,fragility-flagging: resolved.assumption-enumeration: intermediate (only package-prefixed variants exist).
Preserved source criteria ledger
- Preserve multi-model convergence and explicit fragility reporting.
Context checkpoint / Delta notes
Append variants, changed assumptions, convergence results, and fragility flags.
