select-critical-case
Purpose
Select most-likely, least-likely, or otherwise inference-maximizing cases that can decisively support or refute a claim.
Input contract
required: [claim, case_universe, selection_logic]
optional: [likelihood_model, boundary_conditions]
constraints: [case selection rule and inference purpose must be explicit]
Procedure
- Define the eligible case universe and selection objective.
- Rank cases under the declared logic.
- Select and justify the critical case, including excluded cases.
Output contract
produces: [critical_case, selection_rationale, excluded_cases, inference_role]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions]
Quality gates
- Selected case must be traceable to the stated selection logic.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not call a convenient case critical without comparing it to the declared universe.
Provenance map
- resolved: critical-case-design
- resolved: counterexample-heuristics
