select-seed-evidence
Purpose
Select and rank high-information seed sources for iterative evidence expansion using quality, recency, relevance, and network position.
Input contract
required: [candidate_sources, research_question, selection_criteria]
optional: [citation_graph, quality_assessments, recency_window]
constraints: [rank rationale and source independence must be explicit]
Procedure
- Score candidate sources against relevance, quality, recency, diversity, and network position.
- Remove dependent duplicates and preserve complementary seeds.
- Select seeds covering distinct mechanisms, populations, or evidence gaps.
- Record expected expansion value and unresolved selection uncertainty.
If the seed set spans the protocol's main evidence types, consider categorize-evidence as the next tactic.
Output contract
produces: [seed_set, ranking_rationale, diversity_coverage, expansion_questions]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]
Quality gates
- Seed choice is not citation-count-only.
- Independent sources and complementary coverage are visible.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not select only the most cited source or treat a review and its included primary study as independent seeds.
Provenance map
resolved: knowledge-acquisition-seed-selection
