set-threshold
Purpose
Define a justified minimum acceptable threshold for each non-compensatory criterion.
Input contract
required: [criteria, value_domains, decision_context, evidence]
optional: [baseline_distribution, veto_policy, stakeholder_preferences]
constraints: [each threshold lies in the criterion's actual value domain and has an explicit rationale]
Procedure
- State each criterion's domain, direction, and failure meaning.
- Gather empirical, structural, and decision-context evidence for a minimum acceptable value.
- Set the threshold and record rationale, uncertainty, and veto semantics.
- Return the threshold set for non-compensatory screening.
Output contract
produces: [threshold_set, rationale_by_criterion, veto_policy, uncertainty_notes]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, decisions, uncertainties]
Quality gates
- Every threshold has a rationale and lies within the criterion's actual value range.
- Thresholds are exposed to downstream screening; they are not hidden in prose.
- Relative thresholds, when used for evidence coverage, declare universe, numerator, denominator, batch increment, stopping reason, source references, direction, and threshold rationale.
Parameterization
The caller must provide criteria, domains and direction, evidence, baseline distribution if available, minimum-acceptable semantics, and whether the threshold is a veto or ordinary non-compensatory floor.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject thresholds outside the domain, unsupported by rationale, or treated as compensable weights when the caller specified a veto.
Provenance map
- resolved: convergence/threshold-setting
- intermediate: Pass4/define-success-criteria
Preserved source criteria ledger
| source |
physical line |
kind |
source criterion |
| convergence/threshold-setting |
13 |
gate |
Every minimum threshold includes a rationale and lies in the criterion's actual value domain. |
1---2name: set-threshold3description: "Define a justified minimum acceptable threshold for each non-compensatory criterion."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/yogsoth-ai/set-threshold6---78# set-threshold910## Purpose1112Define a justified minimum acceptable threshold for each non-compensatory criterion.1314## Input contract1516```yaml17required: [criteria, value_domains, decision_context, evidence]18optional: [baseline_distribution, veto_policy, stakeholder_preferences]19constraints: [each threshold lies in the criterion's actual value domain and has an explicit rationale]20```2122## Procedure23241. State each criterion's domain, direction, and failure meaning.252. Gather empirical, structural, and decision-context evidence for a minimum acceptable value.263. Set the threshold and record rationale, uncertainty, and veto semantics.274. Return the threshold set for non-compensatory screening.2829## Output contract3031```yaml32produces: [threshold_set, rationale_by_criterion, veto_policy, uncertainty_notes]33delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, decisions, uncertainties]34```3536## Quality gates3738- Every threshold has a rationale and lies within the criterion's actual value range.39- Thresholds are exposed to downstream screening; they are not hidden in prose.40- Relative thresholds, when used for evidence coverage, declare universe, numerator, denominator, batch increment, stopping reason, source references, direction, and threshold rationale.4142## Parameterization4344The caller must provide criteria, domains and direction, evidence, baseline distribution if available, minimum-acceptable semantics, and whether the threshold is a veto or ordinary non-compensatory floor.4546## Failure and counterexamples4748Reject thresholds outside the domain, unsupported by rationale, or treated as compensable weights when the caller specified a veto.4950## Provenance map5152- resolved: convergence/threshold-setting53- intermediate: Pass4/define-success-criteria5455## Preserved source criteria ledger5657| source | physical line | kind | source criterion |58|---|---:|---|---|59| convergence/threshold-setting | 13 | gate | Every minimum threshold includes a rationale and lies in the criterion's actual value domain. |60