specify-boundaries
Purpose
Specify the population, system, temporal, and conceptual boundaries within which a claim or study is intended to hold.
Input contract
required: [claim_or_question, target_context]
optional: [known_limits, adjacent_domains, time_window]
constraints: [each boundary must be observable or operationally enforceable]
Procedure
- Identify included and excluded populations, systems, conditions, and times.
- Separate conceptual boundaries from practical sampling limits.
- Record boundary rationale and expected failure outside scope.
- Emit a boundary schema for downstream comparison.
Output contract
produces: [boundary_specification, inclusion_edges, exclusion_edges, extrapolation_limits]
delta_fields: [decisions, assumption_updates, uncertainties, open_questions]
Quality gates
- Boundaries do not depend on observed outcomes.
- Extrapolation limits are explicit.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not define the boundary as whatever data happen to be available.
Provenance map
resolved: specify-boundaries
