trace-assumption-cascade
Purpose
Trace downstream claims, methods, and conclusions that fail when a selected assumption is invalidated.
Input contract
required: [assumption, dependency_graph, downstream_claims]
optional: [failure_evidence, intervention]
constraints: [each cascade edge must identify dependency and failure mechanism]
Procedure
- Identify the assumption and immediate dependents.
- Propagate invalidation through claims, methods, and conclusions.
- Distinguish local from cascading failure and record recovery points.
If the cascade identifies conclusions controlled by a small assumption set, consider search-minimal-flip as the next tactic.
Output contract
produces: [assumption_cascade, affected_claims, local_failures, cascading_failures, recovery_points]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, open_questions]
Quality gates
- A-class cascade coverage: declared universe = all downstream nodes reachable from the selected assumption; numerator = nodes with an assessed dependency and failure status; batch increment = one dependency layer; stopping reason = no new reachable nodes or marginal new impact is below a justified threshold; source references = dependency edges, assumption IDs, evidence IDs; direction/threshold reason = continue while newly reached nodes materially change decision or risk.
Failure and counterexamples
Do not infer cascade from naming or proximity; require a dependency edge.
Provenance map
- resolved: assumption-cascade
