validate-research-gap
Purpose
Test whether an apparent research gap is real, persistent, and not an evidence-acquisition artifact, and keep the candidates rejected along the way auditable.
Input contract
required: [gap_claim, evidence_set, search_scope]
optional: [independent_sources, time_slices, candidate_gap_types]
constraints: [absence claims require an explicit scope and retrieval record]
Execution protocol
Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.
- You MUST load skill
verify-evidence-independence to check source independence.
- You MUST load skill
filter-false-gap to separate open, touched-but-not-closed, and false gaps.
- You MUST load skill
analyze-temporal-trajectory to test persistence across time.
- You MUST load skill
classify-research-gap to classify each validated gap, including those prior work touches without closing.
If several validated gaps require comparative priority, consider rank-candidates. If stakeholder boundaries determine whether the gap matters, consider map-stakeholder-system.
Deviation: if temporal data are unavailable, return persistence unknown rather than infer stability.
Output contract
produces: [gap_validity_verdict, independence_check, persistence_assessment, typed_gap, rejection_register]
delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]
Thresholds and quality gates
- B: independence, search adequacy, persistence, and gap type are separately reported; unsearched space is not a confirmed gap.
- B: every candidate rejected as resolved appears in the rejection register with its closing work; a rejection resting on a single source is flagged.
- When the typology admits contradiction, measurement, or boundary gaps and none is reported, the verdict states why.
Failure and counterexamples
Reject gaps caused by duplicate sources, narrow retrieval, prior work that closes the question, or unanswerable wording. Do not reject a gap because prior work exists in its region.
Provenance map
deep-insight/gap-validation, cross-validation, cross-database-verification, false-gap-filtering, temporal-sensitivity-testing: resolved.
Preserved source criteria ledger
- Preserve cross-source verification, false-gap filtering, and temporal persistence checks.
Context checkpoint / Delta notes
Append source set, independence findings, temporal updates, gap verdicts, rejection register, and next action.
1---2name: validate-research-gap3description: "Test whether an apparent gap is real, persistent, and not an evidence-acquisition artifact, keeping every candidate rejected as closed on record. Tool choice is left to the host AI."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/yogsoth-ai/validate-research-gap6---78# validate-research-gap9## Purpose10Test whether an apparent research gap is real, persistent, and not an evidence-acquisition artifact, and keep the candidates rejected along the way auditable.11## Input contract12```yaml13required: [gap_claim, evidence_set, search_scope]14optional: [independent_sources, time_slices, candidate_gap_types]15constraints: [absence claims require an explicit scope and retrieval record]16```17## Execution protocol18Do not perform called SOP operations inline; each loaded SOP owns its contract and thresholds.19201. You MUST load skill `verify-evidence-independence` to check source independence.212. You MUST load skill `filter-false-gap` to separate open, touched-but-not-closed, and false gaps.223. You MUST load skill `analyze-temporal-trajectory` to test persistence across time.234. You MUST load skill `classify-research-gap` to classify each validated gap, including those prior work touches without closing.24 If several validated gaps require comparative priority, consider `rank-candidates`. If stakeholder boundaries determine whether the gap matters, consider `map-stakeholder-system`.25Deviation: if temporal data are unavailable, return persistence unknown rather than infer stability.26## Output contract27```yaml28produces: [gap_validity_verdict, independence_check, persistence_assessment, typed_gap, rejection_register]29delta_fields: [findings, evidence_updates, uncertainties, decisions, recommended_jumps]30```31## Thresholds and quality gates32- B: independence, search adequacy, persistence, and gap type are separately reported; unsearched space is not a confirmed gap.33- B: every candidate rejected as resolved appears in the rejection register with its closing work; a rejection resting on a single source is flagged.34- When the typology admits contradiction, measurement, or boundary gaps and none is reported, the verdict states why.35## Failure and counterexamples36Reject gaps caused by duplicate sources, narrow retrieval, prior work that closes the question, or unanswerable wording. Do not reject a gap because prior work exists in its region.37## Provenance map38- `deep-insight/gap-validation`, `cross-validation`, `cross-database-verification`, `false-gap-filtering`, `temporal-sensitivity-testing`: resolved.39## Preserved source criteria ledger40- Preserve cross-source verification, false-gap filtering, and temporal persistence checks.41## Context checkpoint / Delta notes42Append source set, independence findings, temporal updates, gap verdicts, rejection register, and next action.