U0141 Tooling Plan Quality Evaluator

Tooling Plan Quality Evaluator

Why This Skill Exists

We need this skill because automation collapses when tools are flaky and failure modes are opaque. This specific skill quantifies whether plans are complete, safe, and feasible.

When To Use

Use this skill when the request explicitly needs "Tooling Plan Quality Evaluator" outcomes in the Tool Reliability and Execution Quality domain.

Step-by-Step Implementation Guide

1. Define the scope and success metrics for Tooling Plan Quality Evaluator, including at least three measurable KPIs tied to silent failures and cascading retries.
2. Design and version the input/output contract for tool runs, error signatures, and retry outcomes, then add schema validation and failure-mode handling.
3. Implement the core capability using multi-criteria plan scoring, and produce plan quality scorecards with deterministic scoring.
4. Integrate the skill into swarm orchestration: task routing, approval gates, retry strategy, and rollback controls.
5. Add unit, integration, and simulation tests that explicitly cover silent failures and cascading retries, then run regression baselines.
6. Deploy behind a feature flag, monitor telemetry/alerts for two release cycles, and iterate thresholds based on observed outcomes.

Required Deliverables

• Capability contract: input schema, deterministic scoring, output schema, and failure modes.
• Runtime profile: general-capability using multi-criteria plan scoring to produce plan quality scorecards.
• Orchestration integration: tool-reliability-and-execution-quality:general-capability routing, approval gates, retries, and rollback controls.
• Validation evidence: unit, integration, simulation, regression-baseline suites and rollout telemetry.

Operational Runbook

Preflight

• Confirm the Tooling Plan Quality Evaluator request scope, source evidence, and measurable success criteria before execution.
• Verify feature flag skill_0141_tooling-plan-quality-evaluator, approval gates, and rollback owner before autonomous use.

Execution

• Execute multi-criteria plan scoring with deterministic scoring and reproducible trace capture.
• Produce plan quality scorecards plus scorecard, assumptions, and unresolved-risk notes.

Recovery

• Fail closed when required signals, evidence, or approval gates are missing.
• Rollback to the last stable baseline when posture is critical or validation fails.

Handoff

• Publish plan quality scorecards, validation evidence, and telemetry links to downstream owners.
• Queue follow-up tasks for unresolved risks, threshold tuning, or approval review.

Guardrails

• [quality] Require deterministic scoring and validation evidence before promotion.
• [reliability] Preserve retries, rollback controls, and failure-mode evidence for every run.
• [safety] Route critical posture or missing approval gates to human review before autonomous action.