1---2name: analyze-mfn-waterfall-analysis3task_id: funds-asset-management/analyze-mfn-waterfall-analysis4description: Review a fund's governing fund documents, a set of individual LP side letters, a GP policy memo, a tracking spreadsheet, and a capital commitment schedule at closing to produce a comprehensive MFN waterfall analysis and recommendation memorandum with LP-by-LP eligibility determinations, economic comparisons, cascade analysis, and pre-notice amendment recommendations.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/analyze-mfn-waterfall-analysis8---910# Skill: MFN Waterfall Analysis — Comprehensive Final-Closing Memo1112## 1. Subject-matter triage13- Treat the fund agreement, side letters, policy memo, tracking spreadsheet, and capital commitment schedule as a layered record: the fund documents set the baseline, each side letter can alter only the relevant LP’s rights, and the closing schedule determines who can compare against whom.14- If the task includes multiple LPs, closings, or election tiers, enumerate them first and analyze each one separately before comparing outcomes.15- Do not rely on the spreadsheet’s labels as dispositive; use it as a guide, then confirm each point from the governing text.1617## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting18- Relying on a tracking spreadsheet’s categorizations rather than independently determining each LP’s MFN eligibility from the side letter text.19- Missing that a later-closing LP can become the benchmark for earlier-closing LPs when it negotiates more favorable economics.20- Failing to analyze aggregation rights that may let an LP reach a higher MFN tier and thereby trigger a broader cascade.21- Overlooking drafting defects in side letters that should be corrected before MFN notice goes out, so the defect does not become the reference term for elections.22- Treating unusual governance concessions as non-economic when they can still flow through MFN provisions unless clearly excluded.2324## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply25- Determine MFN eligibility LP by LP from the side letter text: whether an MFN clause exists, whether it is full or limited, the applicable commitment threshold, and which other terms are available for election based on commitment size and closing date.26- An LP without an MFN clause cannot elect preferential terms, even if those terms are available to others.27- Later-closing LPs may provide the best economics for earlier-closing LPs; compare fee and carry economics separately for earlier and later closing groups.28- For governance terms, assess whether the term falls within a standard MFN exclusion category or is an unusual concession that may still cascade absent a clear carveout.29- Use the governing authority in the source set for MFN notice timing, election mechanics, and any stated exclusions; if the source set is silent, apply the fund’s own contractual hierarchy and standard fund-document reading principles.3031## 4. Analytical scaffolds321. Build an LP-by-LP table from the side letters: MFN presence, scope, threshold, closing date, commitment amount, and election-eligible terms.332. Identify the MFN notice deadline and the point by which any needed amendments must be completed.343. Identify the later-closing LP or LPs and determine whether they provide the most favorable economics available to earlier closings.354. Separate analysis of management fee and carry: identify the best available rate for each closing group and assess cascade risk within each group.365. Model fee impact using the commitment schedule and closing data; state the baseline, then the downside and expected cascade paths.376. Model carry impact at representative return outcomes using the lowest carry term available in the source documents.387. Evaluate no-fault removal or similar governance thresholds for cascade effects by looking at the aggregate commitments of LPs who can elect the lower threshold.398. Review any side-letter drafting error that should be corrected before notice; recommend amendment before circulation.409. If an LP may aggregate with affiliates or related vehicles, determine the post-aggregation tier and then re-run the election analysis from that tier.4110. Characterize co-investment guarantees against commercially reasonable efforts and fair-allocation language; assess whether the guarantee can spread through MFN rights.4211. Enumerate any expanded key person lists and assess whether they enlarge the fund’s overall key-person exposure if elected by others.4312. Test unusual rights, including valuation-agent approval, against the policy memo’s exclusion architecture and flag any ambiguity for counsel.4413. Distinguish relationship-driven concessions from excluded terms only if the source documents clearly support the carveout; otherwise treat them as potentially electable.4514. End with concrete action items tied to the closing timetable and notice process.4647## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships48- The fund agreement sits at the base; side letters overlay it; the policy memo may narrow or categorize terms; the closing schedule determines which LPs can compare terms across closing groups.49- Earlier closings generally compare upward to later closings only to the extent the MFN language and closing mechanics permit.50- Pre-notice amendments must be completed before MFN notices are delivered, or the flawed term can become the reference point for elections.51- Aggregation analysis is circular by design: aggregation can move an LP into a better tier, and that better tier can then affect cascade outcomes for others.5253## 6. Output structure conventions54- Produce a single recommendation memorandum as the deliverable.55- Use a conventional memo shape: opening summary, LP-level eligibility matrix, economics comparison by closing group, issue-by-issue analysis, cascade impact modeling, and recommended next steps.56- For each identified issue, state the scale or threshold implicated, identify the document interaction that matters, and explain the downstream consequence for the fund or LPs.57- Use an explicit severity label for each issue, with a uniform ordinal scale defined once at the start of the analysis.58- Close the memorandum with a Recommended Actions section that assigns each action to the relevant role and ties timing to the MFN notice process or final-closing timeline.59- Cite the controlling contractual provision, policy rule, or other source authority whenever stating a legal or interpretive conclusion.60- Keep the analysis grounded in the source documents; do not assume a term is excluded, electable, or non-electable without tracing it through the governing text.