Summarize a thread faithfully
A summary that flattens dissent into consensus becomes the record people cite. Carry attribution, unresolved disagreement, and open questions intact.
Procedure
Read the whole thread before writing a line; a summary built from the top misrepresents the end.
Capture each distinct position, attributed: "A argued X; B proposed Y because Z."
Preserve unresolved disagreement explicitly; never average it into false consensus.
List decisions made, each with the message that made it.
List open questions and who owes the answer.
Mark your own additions as
[summary author: ...]so they are not read as thread content.Keep quotations short and verbatim; paraphrase can invert meaning.
Pitfalls
- Dropping minority dissent produces a summary the thread itself would reject.
- Attributing a paraphrase to someone who did not say it misrepresents them.
- Picking a side without flagging it hides the decision from the reader.
- Omitting open questions makes the thread look closed when it is not.
- Summarising from memory rather than the log loses the exact wording that matters.
Verification
grep -cE "^(Decision|Open|Disagreement):" summary.md # each class present when it exists
Summarise positions, decisions, dissent, and open questions, each with attribution.