Scope
Do: review vendor SOC 2 reports, DDQs, contracts, CUECs, exceptions, subservice organizations, residual risks, public research, and vendor questions Do not: issue a risk rating, score, tier, or approval decision, paraphrase the opinion, treat out-of-scope criteria or carve-outs as covered, mark CUECs adopted without evidence, send anything to the vendor
When NOT to Use
- Researching a customer or beneficial owner — use
kyc-research-packinstead. - Triaging a regulatory change — use
reg-change-triageinstead. - Formatting, charting, or restyling an existing workbook — use
xlsxinstead.
Third-Party / Vendor Risk Review
Read the report properly, surface what it does and does not cover, and hand a reviewer the open questions.
No risk rating. No tier. No approval or rejection. Those are the third-party risk owner's
determinations — house-rules.md § 2.
Framework: the interagency guidance on third-party relationships (OCC Bulletin 2023-17 and its interagency counterparts), which rescinded OCC 2013-29 and 2020-10.
Read first
Read these in full before step 1. They are binding; this body only summarises them.
references/workflow.md— the full text of every step below, with the guardrails, source resolution, and footer detail.references/house-rules.md— destination gate, determination gate, identity resolution, markers, footers, and § 12 data minimisation (every artifact, search, and chat reply).references/reg-source-access.md— retrieving rules and guidance the review cites.references/document-extraction.md§ 4 — SOC 2 extraction. The field list there is mandatory.references/vendor-outline.md— default memo and exceptions table: the output format.references/self-check.md— the final self-check (step 9).
Workflow
1. Establish what you were given
Detail: workflow.md § 1. A "SOC 2" is often something else. Type II → proceed. Type I → design
at a point in time only, flagged. SOC 3 → no exceptions or CUECs. Bridge letter → management's
unaudited assertion. ISO certificate → a different framework. DDQ → self-reported and untested.
Marketing summary → GAP — supplied document is a summary, not the report. Scanned reports are
read with OCR.
2. Extract the mandatory fields
Detail: workflow.md § 2. Type · report period · criteria in scope · systems and locations ·
opinion type · exceptions · CUECs · subservice organizations and their treatment. A missing field
is a finding.
- Period: state the uncovered part explicitly, in months and
calendar days. - Criteria: out-of-scope criteria are untested, not passed.
- Subservice organizations: carve-out means not tested; list each one and what it does.
3. Quote the opinion — never paraphrase
Detail: workflow.md § 3. Quote the opinion paragraph, and a qualified opinion's basis
paragraph, verbatim. Every locator is read, not guessed: cite the section heading and page
printed where each quote sits, and re-open the page in the self-check.
4. Extract exceptions in full
Detail: workflow.md § 4. The control · the auditor's description verbatim · management's
response verbatim · any auditor comment · items tested and deviations ("2 of 25"). Never "minor"
or "not material".
5. Complementary user-entity controls — the point of the exercise
Detail: workflow.md § 5. Extract every CUEC: adopted only with cited evidence, not adopted
(an open risk the firm owns), otherwise NOT DETERMINED — owner confirms. State the count
prominently. A clean opinion with unadopted CUECs is not a clean result; say so in those words.
6. Public research — labelled, not exhaustive
Detail: workflow.md § 6. Adverse media, litigation, breaches, regulatory actions. Attribute
only with a corroborating identifier, else UNRESOLVED MATCH. Every adverse item keeps its
disposition. State what was searched and its limits; never "no adverse findings". No screening
connector → NEEDS FEED — screening provider, and the pass is labelled research, not a screen.
Rejected hits about private individuals are named by site and page type only: no titles, no URL
paths, captions as [another individual] v. <entity>.
7. Residual risks and open questions
Detail: workflow.md § 7. Residual risks: out-of-scope criteria, the period gap, carve-outs,
unadopted CUECs, untested remediations, each with its source. Open questions for the vendor are
specific and answerable.
8. Emit the memo, table, and draft handoff
Detail: workflow.md § 8. docx builds the memo and xlsx the workbook, per
vendor-outline.md. A TPRM connector is read for pre-fill only; the deliverable is a draft
export for the risk owner. Still no rating.
9. Final self-check, then count
- Save the artifact text, the chat reply (
reply.md), and the search log (searches.md: oneREQ | <source> | ok / failed / not attemptedline per request and oneHIT | <query> | <document> | used / rejected (Gn) / duplicate (Gn) / set asideline per document returned). - Run
python scripts/lint_deliverable.py <artifact> --reply reply.md --searches searches.md. Fix everyERROR, resolve everyCHECK, and re-run until it printsERROR: 0(house-rules.md§ 13). - Work through every item in
references/self-check.md, re-opening the page for every quote locator. - Build the footer counts from the G-list and D-list last, then recount.
Guardrails
Full list: workflow.md, Guardrails.
- No risk rating, score, tier, or approval decision.
- Never paraphrase the opinion; never describe out-of-scope criteria as passed or a carve-out as covered.
- Never mark a CUEC adopted without evidence; never call an exception minor or immaterial.
- Never present a Type I as operating effectiveness, or a DDQ or bridge letter as assured.
- Never write "no adverse findings"; never attribute research without identity resolution.
- Never fabricate. Never claim a save succeeded when it failed. Nothing is sent to the vendor or committed in a source system.
Output footer
Per house-rules.md § 9 and workflow.md, Output footer: destination · document type supplied ·
report type and period · review period not covered · criteria in and out of scope · opinion
quoted · exception count · CUEC count and how many confirmed adopted · subservice treatment ·
research coverage and limits · connectors · open items by marker type · determinations
outstanding · draft export, no source-system update · files and save result · template used.
Example
Input: <vendor> SOC 2 Type II, Security only, period ended 2026-06-30.
Output: Review period not covered: GAP - period mismatch: 92 calendar days not covered (G1).
Privacy: GAP - scope: Privacy criteria outside the report's scope, untested (G2).
CUECs: 8 specified; each NOT DETERMINED - owner confirms adoption (D1 to D8).
Question: Confirm whether Privacy will be in scope next period (G2).
Handoff: Draft TPRM export prepared; no source-system update performed.
Reference files
references/workflow.md— full step text, guardrails, source resolution, footer detail.references/self-check.md— the final self-check.references/house-rules.md— gates, identity resolution, markers, footers, the lint step.references/document-extraction.md— SOC 2 mandatory fields, CUECs, subservice treatment.references/reg-source-access.md— retrieving rules and guidance the review cites.references/vendor-outline.md— default memo, exceptions and CUEC tables.