Pedagogy Review

Pedagogical Review of Lecture Slides

Perform a comprehensive pedagogical review using the PhD econometrics student lens.

Steps

1. Identify the file specified in $ARGUMENTS

   • If no argument, ask user which lecture to review
   • If just a name (e.g., Lecture4_StaggeredRollout.qmd), look in Quarto/
   • If .tex file, look in Slides/

2. Launch the pedagogy-reviewer agent with the full file path

   • The agent reads the entire file
   • Checks 12 pedagogical patterns distilled from completed lectures
   • Performs deck-level analysis (narrative arc, pacing, visual rhythm, notation consistency)
   • Considers PhD student perspective (prerequisites, potential objections)

3. The agent produces a report saved to: quality_reports/[FILENAME_WITHOUT_EXT]_pedagogy_report.md

4. Present summary to user:

   • Patterns followed vs violated (out of 12)
   • Deck-level assessments (narrative arc, pacing, notation)
   • Critical recommendations (top 3-5)

Important Notes

• This is a read-only review — no files are edited
• The agent uses a PhD student lens — assumes advanced econometrics background but checks that cutting-edge panel methods are introduced properly
• Focuses on pedagogy not visual layout (use /visual-audit for that)
• For a combined review of everything, use /slide-excellence instead