Expected Value
Table of Contents
Core Formula
EV = Σ (Probability of outcome x Value of outcome)
EV = (p₁ × v₁) + (p₂ × v₂) + ... + (pₙ × vₙ)
where probabilities must sum to 1.0
Example: Launch feature with 60% chance of +$100k incremental net payoff, 40% chance of -$20k future net loss.
EV = (0.6 x $100k) + (0.4 x -$20k) = $60k - $8k = $52k (positive EV, rational to launch if risk tolerance allows)
Workflow
Copy this checklist and track your progress:
Expected Value Analysis Progress:
- [ ] Step 1: Define decision and alternatives
- [ ] Step 2: Identify possible outcomes
- [ ] Step 3: Estimate probabilities
- [ ] Step 4: Estimate payoffs (values)
- [ ] Step 5: Calculate expected values
- [ ] Step 6: Interpret and adjust for risk preferences
Step 1: Define decision and alternatives
What decision are you making? What are the mutually exclusive options? See resources/template.md.
Step 2: Identify possible outcomes
For each alternative, what could happen? List scenarios from best case to worst case. See resources/template.md.
Step 3: Estimate probabilities
What's the probability of each outcome? Use base rates, reference classes, expert judgment, data. See resources/methodology.md.
Step 4: Estimate payoffs (values)
What's the value (gain or loss) of each outcome? Quantify in dollars, time, utility. See resources/methodology.md.
Step 5: Calculate expected values
Multiply probabilities by payoffs, sum across outcomes for each alternative. See resources/template.md.
Step 6: Interpret and adjust for risk preferences
Choose option with highest EV? Or adjust for risk aversion, non-monetary factors, strategic value. See resources/methodology.md.
Validate using resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json. Minimum standard: Average score ≥ 3.5.
Common Patterns
Pattern 1: Investment Decision (Discrete Outcomes)
- Structure: Go/no-go choice with 3-5 discrete scenarios (best, base, worst case)
- Use case: Product launch, hire vs. not hire, accept investment offer, buy vs. lease
- Pros: Simple, intuitive, easy to communicate (decision tree visualization)
- Cons: Oversimplifies continuous distributions, binary framing may miss nuance
- Example: Launch product feature (60% success $100k, 40% fail -$20k) → EV = $52k
Pattern 2: Portfolio Allocation (Multiple Options)
- Structure: Allocate budget across N projects, each with own EV and risk profile
- Use case: Venture portfolio, R&D budget, marketing spend allocation, team capacity
- Pros: Diversification reduces variance, can optimize for risk/return tradeoff
- Cons: Requires estimates for many variables, correlations matter (not independent)
- Example: Invest in 3 startups ($50k each), EVs = [$20k, $15k, -$10k]. Total EV = $25k. Diversified portfolio reduces risk vs. single $150k bet.
Pattern 3: Sequential Decision (Decision Tree)
- Structure: Series of decisions over time, outcomes of early decisions affect later options
- Use case: Clinical trials (Phase I → II → III), staged investment, explore then exploit
- Pros: Captures optionality (can stop if early results bad), fold-back induction finds optimal strategy
- Cons: Tree grows exponentially, need probabilities for all branches
- Example: Phase I drug trial (70% pass, $1M cost) → if pass, Phase II (50% pass, $5M) → if pass, Phase III (40% approve, $50M revenue). Calculate EV working backwards.
Pattern 4: Continuous Distribution (Monte Carlo)
- Structure: Outcomes are continuous (revenue could be $0-$1M), use probability distributions
- Use case: Financial modeling, project timelines, resource planning, sensitivity analysis
- Pros: Captures full uncertainty, avoids discrete scenario bias, provides confidence intervals
- Cons: Requires distributional assumptions, computationally intensive, harder to communicate
- Example: For an assumed Normal($500k, $100k standard deviation) outcome, the analytic mean is $500k and the central 90% outcome interval is approximately [$335.5k, $664.5k]. This is not a confidence interval for the estimated mean or a claimed simulation run.
Pattern 5: Competitive Game (Payoff Matrix)
- Structure: Your outcome depends on competitor's choice, create payoff matrix
- Use case: Pricing strategy, product launch timing, negotiation, auction bidding
- Pros: Incorporates strategic interaction, finds Nash equilibrium
- Cons: Requires estimating competitor's probabilities and payoffs, game-theoretic complexity
- Example: Price high vs. low, competitor prices high vs. low → 2×2 matrix. Calculate EV for each strategy given beliefs about competitor.
Guardrails
Probabilities should sum to 1.0: Listed outcomes need to be exhaustive (cover all possibilities) and mutually exclusive (no overlap). Verify: p1 + p2 + ... + pn = 1.0.
Adjust for risk on one-shot, high-stakes decisions: EV is a long-run average. For rare, irreversible decisions, factor in risk aversion. A 1% chance of $1B (EV = $10M) does not mean betting the house is rational.
Quantify uncertainty, don't hide it: Probabilities and payoffs are estimates. Use ranges, sensitivity analysis, or distributions rather than pretending false precision.
Consider non-monetary value: Some outcomes have utility not captured by money (reputation, learning, optionality, morale). Convert to a common scale or use multi-attribute utility.
Ground probabilities in data: Use base rates, reference classes, data, and expert forecasts rather than gut feel. Check calibration: are "70% confident" predictions right 70% of the time?
Account for correlated outcomes: If outcomes are not independent (e.g., economic downturn affects all portfolio companies), correlation reduces diversification benefit.
Time value of money: Discount future cash flows to present value. EV should use NPV, not nominal values.
Consider option value: In sequential decisions, fold-back induction finds optimal strategy. Factor in the option to stop early, pivot, or wait for more information.
Common pitfalls:
- ❌ Ignoring risk aversion: EV($100k, 50/50) = EV($50k, certain) but most prefer certain $50k. Use utility functions for risk-averse agents.
- ❌ Anchor on single scenario: "Best case is $1M!" → but probability is 5%. Focus on EV, not cherry-picked scenarios.
- ❌ False precision: "Probability = 67.3%" when you're guessing. Use ranges, express uncertainty.
- ❌ Sunk cost fallacy: Past costs are sunk, don't include in forward-looking EV. Only future costs/benefits matter.
- ❌ Ignoring tail risk: Low-probability, high-impact events (0.1% chance of -$10M) can dominate EV. Don't round to zero.
- ❌ Static analysis: Assume you can't update beliefs or change course. Real decisions allow learning and pivoting.
Quick Reference
Key formulas:
Expected Value: EV = Σ (pᵢ × vᵢ) where p = probability, v = value
Expected Utility (for risk aversion): EU = Σ (pᵢ × U(W₀ + vᵢ)), where W₀ is initial wealth and vᵢ is incremental payoff. Check the function domain: square root requires nonnegative final wealth; log requires positive final wealth. Do not take logs or roots of negative incremental payoffs.
- Risk-neutral: U(x) = x (EV = EU)
- Risk-averse: U(x) = √x or U(x) = log(x) (concave)
- Risk-seeking: U(x) = x² (convex)
Net Present Value: NPV = Σ (CF_t / (1+r)^t) where CF = cash flow, r = discount rate, t = time period
Variance (risk measure): Var = Σ (pᵢ × (vᵢ - EV)²)
Standard Deviation: σ = √Var
Coefficient of Variation (risk/return ratio): CV = σ / EV, meaningful only for an appropriate positive ratio-scale outcome with EV > 0. It is undefined at zero and misleading for negative or near-zero EV; it is not a universal ranking rule.
Breakeven probability: p* where EV = 0. Solve: p* × v_success + (1-p*) × v_failure = 0.
Decision rules:
- Maximize EV: Choose option with highest EV (risk-neutral, repeated decisions)
- Maximize EU: Choose option with highest expected utility (risk-averse, incorporates preferences)
- Minimax regret: Minimize maximum regret across scenarios (conservative, avoid worst mistake)
- Satisficing: Choose first option above threshold EV (bounded rationality)
Sensitivity analysis questions:
- How much do probabilities need to change to flip decision?
- What's EV in best case? Worst case? Which variables have most impact?
- At what probability does EV break even (EV = 0)?
Key resources:
- resources/template.md: Decision framing, outcome identification, EV calculation templates, sensitivity analysis
- resources/methodology.md: Probability estimation, payoff quantification, decision tree analysis, utility functions
- resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json: Quality criteria (scenario completeness, probability calibration, payoff quantification, EV interpretation)
Inputs required:
- Decision: What are you choosing between? (2+ mutually exclusive alternatives)
- Outcomes: For each alternative, what could happen? (3-5 scenarios typical)
- Probabilities: How likely is each outcome? (sum to 1.0)
- Payoffs: What's the value (gain/loss) of each outcome? (dollars, time, utility)
Outputs produced:
expected-value-analysis.md: Decision framing, outcome scenarios with probabilities and payoffs, EV calculations, sensitivity analysis, recommendation with risk considerations
1---2name: expected-value3description: >-4 Calculates the expected value of a decision: outcomes, probabilities and payoffs per option,5 then adjustments for risk, time value and option value, with sensitivity and breakeven odds. Use6 when the user asks "is this worth it", "should we do X or Y", "should we exercise our pro-rata /7 follow on", "what's the expected return", or mentions EV, decision trees or risk-adjusted8 return. Not for weighted qualitative criteria (use decision-matrix).9metadata:10 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/the-utopia-studio/expected-value11---1213# Expected Value1415## Table of Contents16- [Workflow](#workflow)17- [Common Patterns](#common-patterns)18- [Guardrails](#guardrails)19- [Quick Reference](#quick-reference)2021## Core Formula2223**EV** = Σ (Probability of outcome x Value of outcome)2425```26EV = (p₁ × v₁) + (p₂ × v₂) + ... + (pₙ × vₙ)27where probabilities must sum to 1.028```2930**Example**: Launch feature with 60% chance of +$100k incremental net payoff, 40% chance of -$20k future net loss.31EV = (0.6 x $100k) + (0.4 x -$20k) = $60k - $8k = **$52k** (positive EV, rational to launch if risk tolerance allows)3233## Workflow3435Copy this checklist and track your progress:3637```38Expected Value Analysis Progress:39- [ ] Step 1: Define decision and alternatives40- [ ] Step 2: Identify possible outcomes41- [ ] Step 3: Estimate probabilities42- [ ] Step 4: Estimate payoffs (values)43- [ ] Step 5: Calculate expected values44- [ ] Step 6: Interpret and adjust for risk preferences45```4647**Step 1: Define decision and alternatives**4849What decision are you making? What are the mutually exclusive options? See [resources/template.md](resources/template.md#decision-framing-template).5051**Step 2: Identify possible outcomes**5253For each alternative, what could happen? List scenarios from best case to worst case. See [resources/template.md](resources/template.md#outcome-identification-template).5455**Step 3: Estimate probabilities**5657What's the probability of each outcome? Use base rates, reference classes, expert judgment, data. See [resources/methodology.md](resources/methodology.md#1-probability-estimation-techniques).5859**Step 4: Estimate payoffs (values)**6061What's the value (gain or loss) of each outcome? Quantify in dollars, time, utility. See [resources/methodology.md](resources/methodology.md#2-payoff-quantification).6263**Step 5: Calculate expected values**6465Multiply probabilities by payoffs, sum across outcomes for each alternative. See [resources/template.md](resources/template.md#ev-calculation-template).6667**Step 6: Interpret and adjust for risk preferences**6869Choose option with highest EV? Or adjust for risk aversion, non-monetary factors, strategic value. See [resources/methodology.md](resources/methodology.md#4-risk-preferences-and-utility).7071Validate using [resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json](resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json). **Minimum standard**: Average score ≥ 3.5.7273## Common Patterns7475**Pattern 1: Investment Decision (Discrete Outcomes)**76- **Structure**: Go/no-go choice with 3-5 discrete scenarios (best, base, worst case)77- **Use case**: Product launch, hire vs. not hire, accept investment offer, buy vs. lease78- **Pros**: Simple, intuitive, easy to communicate (decision tree visualization)79- **Cons**: Oversimplifies continuous distributions, binary framing may miss nuance80- **Example**: Launch product feature (60% success $100k, 40% fail -$20k) → EV = $52k8182**Pattern 2: Portfolio Allocation (Multiple Options)**83- **Structure**: Allocate budget across N projects, each with own EV and risk profile84- **Use case**: Venture portfolio, R&D budget, marketing spend allocation, team capacity85- **Pros**: Diversification reduces variance, can optimize for risk/return tradeoff86- **Cons**: Requires estimates for many variables, correlations matter (not independent)87- **Example**: Invest in 3 startups ($50k each), EVs = [$20k, $15k, -$10k]. Total EV = $25k. Diversified portfolio reduces risk vs. single $150k bet.8889**Pattern 3: Sequential Decision (Decision Tree)**90- **Structure**: Series of decisions over time, outcomes of early decisions affect later options91- **Use case**: Clinical trials (Phase I → II → III), staged investment, explore then exploit92- **Pros**: Captures optionality (can stop if early results bad), fold-back induction finds optimal strategy93- **Cons**: Tree grows exponentially, need probabilities for all branches94- **Example**: Phase I drug trial (70% pass, $1M cost) → if pass, Phase II (50% pass, $5M) → if pass, Phase III (40% approve, $50M revenue). Calculate EV working backwards.9596**Pattern 4: Continuous Distribution (Monte Carlo)**97- **Structure**: Outcomes are continuous (revenue could be $0-$1M), use probability distributions98- **Use case**: Financial modeling, project timelines, resource planning, sensitivity analysis99- **Pros**: Captures full uncertainty, avoids discrete scenario bias, provides confidence intervals100- **Cons**: Requires distributional assumptions, computationally intensive, harder to communicate101- **Example**: For an assumed Normal($500k, $100k standard deviation) outcome, the analytic mean is $500k and the central 90% outcome interval is approximately [$335.5k, $664.5k]. This is not a confidence interval for the estimated mean or a claimed simulation run.102103**Pattern 5: Competitive Game (Payoff Matrix)**104- **Structure**: Your outcome depends on competitor's choice, create payoff matrix105- **Use case**: Pricing strategy, product launch timing, negotiation, auction bidding106- **Pros**: Incorporates strategic interaction, finds Nash equilibrium107- **Cons**: Requires estimating competitor's probabilities and payoffs, game-theoretic complexity108- **Example**: Price high vs. low, competitor prices high vs. low → 2×2 matrix. Calculate EV for each strategy given beliefs about competitor.109110## Guardrails1111121. **Probabilities should sum to 1.0**: Listed outcomes need to be exhaustive (cover all possibilities) and mutually exclusive (no overlap). Verify: p1 + p2 + ... + pn = 1.0.1131142. **Adjust for risk on one-shot, high-stakes decisions**: EV is a long-run average. For rare, irreversible decisions, factor in risk aversion. A 1% chance of $1B (EV = $10M) does not mean betting the house is rational.1151163. **Quantify uncertainty, don't hide it**: Probabilities and payoffs are estimates. Use ranges, sensitivity analysis, or distributions rather than pretending false precision.1171184. **Consider non-monetary value**: Some outcomes have utility not captured by money (reputation, learning, optionality, morale). Convert to a common scale or use multi-attribute utility.1191205. **Ground probabilities in data**: Use base rates, reference classes, data, and expert forecasts rather than gut feel. Check calibration: are "70% confident" predictions right 70% of the time?1211226. **Account for correlated outcomes**: If outcomes are not independent (e.g., economic downturn affects all portfolio companies), correlation reduces diversification benefit.1231247. **Time value of money**: Discount future cash flows to present value. EV should use NPV, not nominal values.1251268. **Consider option value**: In sequential decisions, fold-back induction finds optimal strategy. Factor in the option to stop early, pivot, or wait for more information.127128**Common pitfalls:**129130- ❌ **Ignoring risk aversion**: EV($100k, 50/50) = EV($50k, certain) but most prefer certain $50k. Use utility functions for risk-averse agents.131- ❌ **Anchor on single scenario**: "Best case is $1M!" → but probability is 5%. Focus on EV, not cherry-picked scenarios.132- ❌ **False precision**: "Probability = 67.3%" when you're guessing. Use ranges, express uncertainty.133- ❌ **Sunk cost fallacy**: Past costs are sunk, don't include in forward-looking EV. Only future costs/benefits matter.134- ❌ **Ignoring tail risk**: Low-probability, high-impact events (0.1% chance of -$10M) can dominate EV. Don't round to zero.135- ❌ **Static analysis**: Assume you can't update beliefs or change course. Real decisions allow learning and pivoting.136137## Quick Reference138139**Key formulas:**140141**Expected Value**: EV = Σ (pᵢ × vᵢ) where p = probability, v = value142143**Expected Utility** (for risk aversion): EU = Σ (pᵢ × U(W₀ + vᵢ)), where W₀ is initial wealth and vᵢ is incremental payoff. Check the function domain: square root requires nonnegative final wealth; log requires positive final wealth. Do not take logs or roots of negative incremental payoffs.144- Risk-neutral: U(x) = x (EV = EU)145- Risk-averse: U(x) = √x or U(x) = log(x) (concave)146- Risk-seeking: U(x) = x² (convex)147148**Net Present Value**: NPV = Σ (CF_t / (1+r)^t) where CF = cash flow, r = discount rate, t = time period149150**Variance** (risk measure): Var = Σ (pᵢ × (vᵢ - EV)²)151152**Standard Deviation**: σ = √Var153154**Coefficient of Variation** (risk/return ratio): CV = σ / EV, meaningful only for an appropriate positive ratio-scale outcome with EV > 0. It is undefined at zero and misleading for negative or near-zero EV; it is not a universal ranking rule.155156**Breakeven probability**: p* where EV = 0. Solve: p* × v_success + (1-p*) × v_failure = 0.157158**Decision rules**:159- **Maximize EV**: Choose option with highest EV (risk-neutral, repeated decisions)160- **Maximize EU**: Choose option with highest expected utility (risk-averse, incorporates preferences)161- **Minimax regret**: Minimize maximum regret across scenarios (conservative, avoid worst mistake)162- **Satisficing**: Choose first option above threshold EV (bounded rationality)163164**Sensitivity analysis questions**:165- How much do probabilities need to change to flip decision?166- What's EV in best case? Worst case? Which variables have most impact?167- At what probability does EV break even (EV = 0)?168169**Key resources:**170- **[resources/template.md](resources/template.md)**: Decision framing, outcome identification, EV calculation templates, sensitivity analysis171- **[resources/methodology.md](resources/methodology.md)**: Probability estimation, payoff quantification, decision tree analysis, utility functions172- **[resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json](resources/evaluators/rubric_expected_value.json)**: Quality criteria (scenario completeness, probability calibration, payoff quantification, EV interpretation)173174**Inputs required:**175- **Decision**: What are you choosing between? (2+ mutually exclusive alternatives)176- **Outcomes**: For each alternative, what could happen? (3-5 scenarios typical)177- **Probabilities**: How likely is each outcome? (sum to 1.0)178- **Payoffs**: What's the value (gain/loss) of each outcome? (dollars, time, utility)179180**Outputs produced:**181- `expected-value-analysis.md`: Decision framing, outcome scenarios with probabilities and payoffs, EV calculations, sensitivity analysis, recommendation with risk considerations